Your overrated/Underrated

[Flexo]

Overrated
Paul Williams
(got exposed by Quintana in the first fight, redeem himself but is a boxer with a lot flaws, cannot beat a motivated Margarito)

Underrated
Sugar Shane Mosley
Still a quality boxer at his age, held his own against Cotto. I see him beating a lot of people in the WW division; even Cotto with a rematch and I'm a Cotto fan.

[KLITSCHKO.]

Underrated:

Andreas Kotelnik
Adrian Diaconu
Sergei Dzinziruk
Joshua Clottey

Overrated:

David Haye
Paul Williams
Ricky Hatton
Zab Judah

[sugarshanenas]

Overrated
Joe calzaghe

PW is far from overrated its just cotto fans overhyping him cause he beat the man who defeated their fighter

[RMAcero]

Overrated
Joel Casamayor - KOed an overrated Katsidis. Still a way-past-it veteran who will lose to Marquez.

Underrated
Andre Berto - May have become champ too soon, but he hits pretty hard and has fast hands. Very effective use of right crosses.

[Mr. Fantastic]

I'm really sorry if this offends anyone....I don't mean anything bad by it.

Overrated:

Kelly Pavlik(I hope he proves me wrong with Hopkins) who I still see as a Great White Hype.

Joe Calzaghe...How many HOFs has he fought? Only Hopkins?

Zab Judah


Underrated:

Paul Williams...Only other guy who has a good claim at being the top Welter...most likely he will fight Margarito next year. Wants to take on the big names.

Clottey......He still gave Margarito a good fight. Both were injured but still put 12 good rounds for the fans.


I didn't mean to offend anyone about kelly pavlik.....like I said, I hope I'm proven wrong.

[Porter's Dad]

Overrated-

Kelly Pavlik
Roy Jones
James Toney
Bernard Hopkins

Underrated-

Joe Calzaghe
Mikkel Kessler
Jeff Lacy
Roy Jones- the 40 year old version
Mario Veit
Tocker Pudwill
Byron Mitchell

[El Dominicano]

Overrated
Joel Casamayor - KOed an overrated Katsidis. Still a way-past-it veteran who will lose to Marquez.

Underrated
Andre Berto - May have become champ too soon, but he hits pretty hard and has fast hands. Very effective use of right crosses.

You never seen Casa fight when he was young???

[El Dominicano]

Overated
Joe Calzaghe
Margarito
Calderon
I can't say Hatton becuz he is undefated at 140.
JMM

Underated
Joan Guzman
Paul Williams
Clottey
Cory Spinks

[bp4pbjr]

Overrated
Antonio Tarver
Waldimir Klitschko
joe calzaghe

Underrated
Ivan Caldren
Clottey
chad dawson

[Mr. Ryan]

Overrated
Paul Williams
(got exposed by Quintana in the first fight, redeem himself but is a boxer with a lot flaws, cannot beat a motivated Margarito)

Underrated
Sugar Shane Mosley
Still a quality boxer at his age, held his own against Cotto. I see him beating a lot of people in the WW division; even Cotto with a rematch and I'm a Cotto fan.

If Margarito was not motivated for the fight with Paul Williams, shame on him. Not being up for undefeated challengers is a flaw in itself.

Mosley, I think his age is an accurate indication of where he is in his career.