Resume Question?

[Flawless.]

joartcc...

You Bull****ting Me

[Live Dog]

You Bull****ting Me

nope....that's the pic in his profile I believe.

[Flawless.]

Look at the fool. It would take a lot of courage not to kill yourself.

[deevel79]

Avoiding the question...nice.

How did i avoid the question? Floyd faced the better opposition throughout his career, while Cotto faced the better opposition at the weight-classes they both shared (140/147)

[Xyei]

Pretty close but from those lists I'd say Floyd has the slight advantage..

[Live Dog]

How did i avoid the question? Floyd faced the better opposition throughout his career, while Cotto faced the better opposition at the weight-classes they both shared (140/147)

first 33 fights...that's the question...Not entire career and/or career at 140/147.

[deevel79]

first 33 fights...that's the question...Not entire career and/or career at 140/147.

Well given that Floyd faced the majority of his "quality" opposition at 130/135, my vote goes to Floyd.

[El Jesus]

How did i avoid the question? Floyd faced the better opposition throughout his career, while Cotto faced the better opposition at the weight-classes they both shared (140/147)

Cotto didint face better opposition at 140, 140 is a mess to this day, the only credible fight that took place there for the longest was hatton/tszyu, everyone else was just a belt holder and that includes cotto, alot of his 140 opponents were common fights that floyd had, there is no way cottos resume is better at 140, its largely the ****ing same, with floyds common opponents aged.

[deevel79]

Cotto didint face better opposition at 140, 140 is a mess to this day, the only credible fight that took place there for the longest was hatton/tszyu, everyone else was just a belt holder and that includes cotto, alot of his 140 opponents were common fights that floyd had, there is no way cottos resume is better at 140, its largely the ****ing same, with floyds common opponents aged.

Floyd had only 3 fights at 140. Corly/Bruseles/Gatti.

Cotto has had over 15 fights at 140, including wins over Malignaggi, and Torres. Those 2 wins alone are better than anything Floyd has done at 140.

So please explain how Floyd's resume is better than Cotto's at 140 again??

[El Jesus]

Floyd had only 3 fights at 140. Corly/Bruseles/Gatti.

Cotto has had over 15 fights at 140, including wins over Malignaggi, and Torres. Those 2 wins alone are better than anything Floyd has done at 140.

So please explain how Floyd's resume is better than Cotto's at 140 again??

I am not saying its better, but i am saying Cottos resume at 140 means very little to me in comparison to floyd save for malignaggi and torres mostly because they share far too many common opponents who started at 130/135 in comparison to floyd. If you want to sit there and say Cottos resume is better than floyds at 147 i would agree, but at 140, most of those guys werent even natural lightweights and had already fought floyd years earlier.