Who wins Margarito or Shane?

[Del Coqui]

I can see Shane giving Margarito problems with his hard chin and Margarito maybe outpointing down the stretch throwing a million punches but this is a great match up, who you got?

[El Jesus]

I dont ever wanna see this fight because it would basically be meaningless, but the shane mosley we know now has been in with some pretty big guys before and struggled, he would have to outwork margarito somehow, i dont know, at this point i really dont know. id have a better grasp of what hed do after the mayorga fight happens because right now i dont think shane really can keep his workrate up in the latter half of fights, and hes always struggled against bigger guys.

[ImAhUstlEBS]

Style's really do make fights and Shane would be a hard task for Tony, with that said though, this would be a barn burner, better then both the Mosley V Cotto and the Margarito V Cotto fight! Ill take Tony by UD, he's got an iron chin with a machine workrate.

[abadger]

Margarito. Shane got a little bit beat up by Cotto, but was able to survive it and come back quite strongly. He wouldn't be able to do that against Marg. it would probably look pretty similar to Marg - Cotto.

[Cuauhtémoc1520]

This past his prime Shane gets beaten.

[Del Coqui]

I dont ever wanna see this fight because it would basically be meaningless, but the shane mosley we know now has been in with some pretty big guys before and struggled, he would have to outwork margarito somehow, i dont know, at this point i really dont know. id have a better grasp of what hed do after the mayorga fight happens because right now i dont think shane really can keep his workrate up in the latter half of fights, and hes always struggled against bigger guys.

He can also clinch, something Cotto failed to do, he's more battle tested

[adrsan84]

At this point in his career I don't think Shane can dig deep enough anymore, I don't think he can win this one because he has slowed down quite a bit and a long powerful fighter would really cause him problems.

[Silencers]

At this point, Margarito by decision. I don't think he'd knock Mosley out and I think Mosley would be capable of making the fight competitive all the way.

[-Antonio-]

He can also clinch, something Cotto failed to do, he's more battle tested

Yeah, that's why I think Shane can do well if he's as game as he was last November.

[Tuggers1986]

This past his prime Shane gets beaten.

Yup Yup Yup