Cotto-Floyd a.k.a Frazior-Ali ??????

[JAB5239]

you may be right.. but i think if Floyd and cotto fought 5 times..Floyd would win 4 times.

but with Cotto i just have a feeling that he could get floyd at least 1 time.


and thats what makes it interesting.

My man, not for nothing, but how can you write THIS yet debate who Floyd should have or haven't fought on the other thread? This is all I want. The best against best. Contrasting styles etc. I don't know you on here well enough to judge you, and Im not going to, but this is like a complete 180. If Im off base, my bad.

[Saloth Sar]

Come on.. Ali and Mayweathers style are completely different..! I have never seen Mayweather dance in the ring or seen Ali do the Shoulder lean. Cotto isn't a knockout puncher like Fraizer were either..! Cotto have growned into a good alround fighter, especially after his fight with Mosley..! I think these 4 people are to different to compare.. I do, however, think Mayweather would beat Cotto easily on a UD. Mayweather is an absolute master of what he does, Cotto is not

huh?

Be a realist.

I can honestly say. That if Floyd and Cotto fought 5 times.
Cotto would win 1 of those fights.

His style is not all pressure with Mayweather would Eat up...! Thats why Margarito wouldnt win 1 round against Mayweather.

Cotto can actually box and actually punch. He is the perfect fit for A great fight with floyd. PERIOD

Floyd would have to fight Cotto.
He wouldnt just be able just Do to cotto what he did to hatton.
he would have to fight Cotto just like how he fought Chavez.

And that would be a great fight to watch

[Sin City]

Come on.. Ali and Mayweathers style are completely different..! I have never seen Mayweather dance in the ring or seen Ali do the Shoulder lean. Cotto isn't a knockout puncher like Fraizer were either..! Cotto have growned into a good alround fighter, especially after his fight with Mosley..! I think these 4 people are to different to compare.. I do, however, think Mayweather would beat Cotto easily on a UD. Mayweather is an absolute master of what he does, Cotto is not

He isn't saying they are carbon copies he is just saying that the story is a little similar.

[judge_jab]

I genuinely believe that Margarito, Cotto and Mayweather are the equivalent of Foreman, Frazier and Ali.

It's Rock paper scissors! Styles make fights,

Cotto (a stocky infighter, frazier) beats a pure boxer, Mayweather (Ali).

Margarito (a tall tough and powerful slugger, Foreman) beats Cotto (Frazier)

Mayweather (Ali) a pure boxer beats A slugger such as Margarito (Foreman!!!

[Saloth Sar]

My man, not for nothing, but how can you write THIS yet debate who Floyd should have or haven't fought on the other thread? This is all I want. The best against best. Contrasting styles etc. I don't know you on here well enough to judge you, and Im not going to, but this is like a complete 180. If Im off base, my bad.

my point was that Mayweather is at a disadvantage at WW. you made it seem like he was on equal terms with everybody. when he is not.

Mayweather and Cotto were in the same division twice 140 and 147.
so i dont compare cotto with the other WW's.

thats why i think Mayweather and cotto would be a fair fight. in which both would have their advantages

[El Dominicano]

I genuinely believe that Margarito, Cotto and Mayweather are the equivalent of Foreman, Frazier and Ali.

It's Rock paper scissors! Styles make fights,

Cotto (a stocky infighter, frazier) beats a pure boxer, Mayweather (Ali).

Margarito (a tall tough and powerful slugger, Foreman) beats Cotto (Frazier)

Mayweather (Ali) a pure boxer beats A slugger such as Margarito (Foreman!!!

Holy ****! I never thought of it that way. Thanks

[JAB5239]

I genuinely believe that Margarito, Cotto and Mayweather are the equivalent of Foreman, Frazier and Ali.

It's Rock paper scissors! Styles make fights,

Cotto (a stocky infighter, frazier) beats a pure boxer, Mayweather (Ali).

Margarito (a tall tough and powerful slugger, Foreman) beats Cotto (Frazier)

Mayweather (Ali) a pure boxer beats A slugger such as Margarito (Foreman!!!

Now how much fun would the welterweight division be if all these guys fought each other as well as the great supporting cast around them. Thats what boxing should be about.

[Big_L]

"I still say Cotto beats Floyd Mayweather. And Mayweather beats Margarito." - William Dettloff

i agree with that too.

[Saloth Sar]

I genuinely believe that Margarito, Cotto and Mayweather are the equivalent of Foreman, Frazier and Ali.

It's Rock paper scissors! Styles make fights,

Cotto (a stocky infighter, frazier) beats a pure boxer, Mayweather (Ali).

Margarito (a tall tough and powerful slugger, Foreman) beats Cotto (Frazier)

Mayweather (Ali) a pure boxer beats A slugger such as Margarito (Foreman!!!

Great point.

While i think cotto could beat Mayweather.
I dont think he is better than Mayweather.

Like I said before.

If they fought 5 times.
Mayweather would win 4.
but I honetly Believe Cotto would win 1.

and Thats why i want to see this fight.

[JAB5239]

my point was that Mayweather is at a disadvantage at WW. you made it seem like he was on equal terms with everybody. when he is not.

Mayweather and Cotto where in the same division twice 140 and 147.
so i dont compare cotto with the other WW's.

thats why i think Mayweather and cotto would be a fair fight. in which both would have their advantages

I will politely disagree with you about the disadvantages you speak of. But even if that is the case, would you not agree that Floyd has advantages in skill and speed over just about every fighter at 147? Like you said, its about styles. But nobody should get a free pass because we might THINK one style would trump another. The best set out to prove it. Thats all Im saying.

I'll be back later. Gotta get to the gym.