So who was the best of these?

[ROSS CALIFORNIA]

Holmes and Lewis, the most skilled. Tyson would have beat either one of them prime for prime, IMO. Lewis would have been a better fight for Tyson though.

[Mo Leicester]

Lennox, Holmes, Tyson, Holyfield and Bowe would be the #1 Hw quite easily. Moorer would lose to Wlad and struggle with the strength of Peter.

As for Douglas,

My opinion on what I've seen is that Holmes and Lewis were the best, closely followed by Tyson.

I did some checking up on Douglas and his record isn't all that great, but the performance he put in against Tyson was beautiful from what I could make out. Looks like he took the money and ran against Holyfield.

[Live Dog]

My opinion on what I've seen is that Holmes and Lewis were the best, closely followed by Tyson.

I did some checking up on Douglas and his record isn't all that great, but the performance he put in against Tyson was beautiful from what I could make out. Looks like he took the money and ran against Holyfield.

Holyfield > Tyson

[Gatti9783]

I voted for Lewis. Very athletic for 6'5". Great power. Brutal right hand. Pretty good chin. He's actually one of my favorite all time heavyweights. I can see Larry Holmes outvoting him though.

[Elie]

Lennox was knocked out twice while still in his prime. I vote for Holmes.

[KJB]

Holmes and Lewis, the most skilled. Tyson would have beat either one of them prime for prime, IMO. Lewis would have been a better fight for Tyson though.

And Holyfield would beat Tyson prime for prime.
I voted for Holyfield. I feel the mans career and legacy have been tarnished by injury/health problems and fighting long past his prime.
Prime Holyfield was a hell of a champion, and would definitely take out Wlad.

[KJB]

Wow 6 votes for Tyson and only 2 for Holyfield?