Roy jones or Floyd Mayweather

[123tyson123]

Need some help guys, who do you rate better in the all time list. Roy Jones jr or Floyd Mayweather jr?

i go with Jones jr but can pick arguements for both.

Im sure they could both be rated in the top ten of all time especially for skilled boxers.

[mojack]

Floyd doesn't even deserve to be on the same thread as RJJ.
Floyd can comeback once he's faught Cotto, Williams and Margarito and then you can make this a competitive thread.

[The Wire]

Floyd Mayweather. He actually fought someone.

[mojack]

The best fighters in boxing are the ones who fight the best fighters in the most memorable fights. Considering Floyd’s last ten opponents, Money Mayweather simply does not qualify.

[TEDetc]

The best fighters in boxing are the ones who fight the best fighters in the most memorable fights. Considering Floyd’s last ten opponents, Money Mayweather simply does not qualify.

I agree, going from super featherweight to super welterweight and winning a world championship belt in each weight class leading up to s.welterweight is no accomplishment at all.

[mojack]

I agree, going from super featherweight to super welterweight and winning a world championship belt in each weight class leading up to s.welterweight is no accomplishment at all.

You have to remember Mayweather only fights older (average age of his opponents have been 34!) or smaller (and slower) competition.

The winning percentage of his opponents after his fights has been less than 40% with less than 30% ending in K.O's! Mayweather is good at picking fights at which he is sure he will win against poor matchups.

But remember he has NOT and will not ever be able to unify the division because he will never fight a younger true welterweight like Cotto, Margs, Williams, in fact he has not fought ANY of the top ten welterweights!

Check his record below the casual fan will be shocked at how poor (and old) his oponents have been!

http://www.boxrec.com/list_bouts.php...=352&cat=boxer

[T-97]

Wel....It's Roy.

But, Mayweather has the advantage of not having people remembering him laid out on his back twice in a row.

[d-1-n-only]

Roy Jones!!!!!!!!

[MANGLER]

Roy all day.

[Live Dog]

Roy likes to take naps during fights....I'll go with PBF.