How can Margarito now be in the P4P list??

[Caxcan]

Yes, but theres one guy at the exact same weight, that holds a win over him recently.

How can he be P4P when someone at his same WEIGHT beat him.

This is why the P4P list doesn't really make sense sometimes.

Yeah the P4P label is really an American thing which is mostly BS but I"m sure they (whoever they are) factored in the loss. IF williams had blow Margarito away the way Margarito blew away Cotto, I doubt he would have cracked the list but it was a competitive fight that went the distance.