The Number One Welter?

[Ryn0]

Tony by far. It is the same issue as the Campbell-Diaz fight. Diaz was considered the best and he was undefeated, and the grizzled veteran took that spot by outworking the younger man. That be like saying you should bring back Robbie Peden and putting him next to Campbell in the list of top lightweights. Back to the subject, Tony is the best welter until someone beats him at that.

But Williams already beat him so I think it's vacant and the rematch should decide.

[JOM'S]

their should be a rematch or an elimination, williams may not be the best but he has win over marg ...

and marg is still the most dangerous ww

[Dan...]

I know Williams beat him but I think you would have to say Margarito is the best at 147 right now. I would definately like to see a rematch though.

[Swizzy]

But Williams already beat him so I think it's vacant and the rematch should decide.

Williams has also shown he is very vulnerable in first fight with Quintana. Knocking-out an undefeated top 5 Pound-4-Pounder you've never fought is more impressive than Knocking-out a guy in the first round who had already beaten you.