Should Jeff Lacy be considert among the greatest of all times?

[Fidayin]

What do you guys think?

I Don't really know much about the guy.

[Phantasm]

A big HELL no. Great guy, solid fighter, but lost in his first REAL big step up in his career and never fought the same again, mostly due to injuries. Showed lots of heart though.

[mspiegelo]

my rankings.

1) jeff lacy
2) ricky hatton
3) botha
4) butterbean
5) sugar ray robinson
6) ali

lacy=best ever!!!! **** yeah bitches!

[Sir_Joe]

No but he should be remembered as one of the most talented fighters of all time in his prime.

[ztrac79]

This can't be a serious question. What has Lacy done to make you think he is anywhere close to being all time anything?

[Fidayin]

I can't find much videos of him on youtube and ive never seen him fight but i have heard a lot about him being a very good fighter.

[TheGreatA]

Now that he has officially retired I can finally put him in my top 10 p4p of all time. I don't think he is better than Sugar Ray Robinson, more talented maybe but he does not quite match the accomplishments.
It's close though with his big wins over Omar Sheika, Syd Vanderpool and Peter Manfredo.

The argument is whether his talent puts him over Armstrong's and Greb's accomplishments or not. I think yes.


Jeff Lacy tribute

[DanielTurcotte3]

No but he should be remembered as one of the most talented fighters of all time in his prime.

???????????

Prime...Hes 31 years old dutchie......Stop building Lacy up too make ya boys reumse look good....Lacy is what everyone knows, talented yes, driven no, scared yes, and limited yes, one dimesional yes.....Now An ATG talent wise in his prime dutchie....Are you iight?!?!?!

[Joe2608]

Jeff Lacy never did anything apart from receive a first class beating from Joe Calzaghe.

[Fidayin]

Now that he has officially retired I can finally put him in my top 10 p4p of all time. I don't think he is better than Sugar Ray Robinson, more talented maybe but he does not quite match the accomplishments.
It's close though with his big wins over Omar Sheika, Syd Vanderpool and Peter Manfredo.

The argument is whether his talent overcome Armstrong's and Greb's accomplishments. I think yes.

And do you rank joe calzaghe higher cause he beat him.