Greatest Fighter All Time Ray Robinson Or Floyd Mayweather?

[dog1dog2]

It's funny when you look at it, but Floyd has less than 20% of SRR's ring experience (1403 career rds for SRR to 275 career rds PBF!!!!). Kind of puts the difference in experience in perspective!

[KJB]

Robinson Is Great Fighter.

He Win Many Many Fights But He Lose A Few Too.

Floyd Retired Undefeated And Beat Many Other Great Fighters.

Sugar Ray And Floyd Very Close In Great.

No, my man, they are not. Floyd Mayweather Jr. is a Great Fighter in his own right, I agree with that.
Sugar Ray Robinson is P4P the Greatest Fighter of All Time, and there is a difference.
I dont feel like writing you an essay on why, but the information is out there. SRR did so many amazing things, and was such an phenom its truly hard to fathom.
They dont call you the best there ever was for no reason.

[dog1dog2]

I don't think anyone is mad at you Ivan...I just think that they feel it isn't really close, and therefore not worth a tremendous amount of discussion. Take it easy...off to bed!

[BHONN]

I Sorry You No Like My Thread.

I Ask You Next Time Before Making Thread Da?

Dolboyob.

Sorry For Thread. You Have Good Morning And Very Good Day.

lols your funny....

anyway if we talk about there skills i bet floyd is already there...
i admire his talent but his a ***** anyway

[El Dominicano]

Lets compare them.

Hand Speed: SRR
Combinations: SRR
Power: SRR
Accuracy: Floyd Mayweather
Defense: Floyd Mayweather
Footwork: Floyd Mayweather
Chin: Can't be proven
Stamina: Tie
Over all skills: Floyd Mayweather
Accomplishment: In my opinion SRR
If they fought I belive SRR would win a U.D! Ofcourse! Because he is just the MUCH BIGGER GUY. P4P I can't pick who'd win

[Rafael Benitez]

5 ******s voted for Floyd. Who is arguably not in the top 10!!! Even in his own era, I think Roy was better.

[Left Hook Tua]

Yep, agreed. Who is it though? Wlad?

it's definitely wladowns.

don't know what's up with the floyd worship though.

funny. leave it to wladowns to have an alt that is actually less annoying than he is. i'd rather talk to this alt than the real wladowns.

still a dumb**** though......

[Tysonisgod]

willie pep would smash both o them

[RibHooker]

Call FLoyd and tell him it's a wrap. He fooled nobody with his touch and go landing. He ran from the best in the division, treated his teenage fans to epic fights like Baldomir and Gatti, and they loved it!!!!!

He is not and never will be a Sugar Ray Robinson. Floyd is definitely a bit slow, IQ wise... this has to be evident. Unless of course, Floyd is a few point above you then you think he is a god. But the BS that comes out of his mouth... the utter gibberish is alarming.


I personally, cannot respect a fighter who tried to sell his legacy based on PPVs and BS one liners. NO SUBSTANCE and he needs to give DLH back his PPV stats. **** was a loan... Floyd is not a draw that is why he doesn't want to fight anybody other than DLH or Hatton. Couldn't sell out in his own hometown....Oscar puts him on, and he tries to act like the PPV god.

[El Dominicano]

I Agree With Every Thing You Say Except Hand Speed.

May Be Floyd Have Faster Hands A Little. No?

Floyd Fight 130-135 In Comparison Ray Fight 147-160.

Maybe Ray Hands Look Faster Because He Fight Slower Enemy? No?

Thank You For Posting Smart Post On My First Thread.

Every One Else Just Mad At Ivan And Say Jokes.

No SRR has faster hand speed. He wasn't as consistent as Mayweather but sometimes he'd explode with a good combination or the left hook.