Where would Mayweather be if He lost the decision to Castillo?

[loui_ludwig]

He would be still #1 and win the trilogy.

[Silencers]

I think he would have been able to work his way to being pound for pound the best after that but nobody can say he's undefeated.

[ferocity]

maybe it makes him better. I don't know. maybe he takes more chances without trying to preserve the 0 and goes up to 154 and 160

hate to admit this, but you are right

[el malo]

LOL at people thinking floyd would move up to 154,160.
let's see him fight a real 147 first like cotto,margarito,mosely

[bsrizpac]

He did lose the decision to Castillo.. it was just some bull**** scoring by the judges.
I would say in the same place considering he did lose it.


38-1 baby!! 39 have tried.. Castillo accomplished!

Post your scorecard with a round by round analysis of why Castillo won the fight.

Then realize you have no idea how to score fights. LOL@you.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Castillo definitely won the first fight. I think the same thing happens, Floyd adjusts, moves around more and boxes his way to a rematch victory. He'd have probably won a fairly boring rubber match too.

[Da Hammer]

i dont think his career would be much different although probably not as much money as he has now and without a doubt a lot less ppl suckin his well u know

[Flawless]

He would be P4P best. He won the first fight and the second was just a beautiful display for boxing.

[El Dominicano]

maybe it makes him better. I don't know. maybe he takes more chances without trying to preserve the 0 and goes up to 154 and 160

In my opinion, A lost would only make Mayweather stronger. Weird that I'd say that because people with huge ego's can't take a lost.

[El Chicano]

First of all, he did lose the fight to Castillo and Second, if the judges got it right, he'd still be on HBO Boxing After Dark, or Showtime.