Top 10 P4P List. Agree? Disagree?

[mspiegelo]

ha ha ha

it's ok. it's suppose to be funny.

i.e. haye over wlad to piss of the wlad guys and raf over his brother to piss off the jmm guys who think he should be higher because jmm beat the #1.

haha. everyones so touchy- good work

[Left Hook Tua]

id put hatton somewhere around 75.... haye hasn't earned it yet and i don't have wlad on there either. he may be the most dominant heavyweight, but his skill ratio to his weight does not make him a "pound for pound"er in my book.

i got

1)Manny
2) Zaghe
3) JMM
4) B-Hop
5) Cotto
6) Pav
7) Izzy
8) Raf
9) Mijares
10) Calderon
11) Winks
12) Suga Shane
13) Guzman

that's a good list. i don't think b-hop deserves to be top 10 though. he has 2 losses to jermain and his win over tarver doesn't count for much 'cause i rate antonio very low. (roy boy bias.)

[dfwtx]

I don't have Haye or Klitschko on my pound for pound list yet. Klitschko has not unified heavyweight and Haye hasn't accomplished enough to be on there as of now. The best names that are on his resume are Mormeck and Macrenelli. Chad Dawson has beaten better fighters than he has.


This is my list.

1. Manny Macquiao
2. Joe Calzaghe
3. Miguel Cotto
4. Juan Manual Marquez
5. Bernard Hopkins
6. Israel Vasquez
7. Kelly Pavlik
8. Cristian Mijares
9. Ivan Calderon
10. Ricky Hatton

That's actually a pretty good list, i would have bhop at a higher number but it's a nice list.

[Mike Tyson77]

fatty tua is P4P#1 hotdog eater

[Left Hook Tua]

I don't have Hatton or Haye in my top 10. Mijares and Calderon need to be in there for mine. Otherwise it is ok.

you have a great list then.

mijares and calderon would've been on my list if i didn't have to have my 1 heavy rule and didn't put haye #9 over wlad.

[Left Hook Tua]

fatty tua is P4P#1 hotdog eater

tua>wlad

[Mike Tyson77]

tua>wlad

Im sure fatty tua could outeat Wlad. But in boxing Wlad would KO fatty tua.

[Left Hook Tua]

Im sure fatty tua could outeat Wlad. But in boxing Wlad would KO fatty tua.

you mean ud12 fatty tua.

scientific studies have shown that tua's chin is the 2nd hardest material on earth. 2nd only to industrial diamonds.



true story.

[Mike Tyson77]

you mean ud12 fatty tua.

scientific studies have shown that tua's chin is the 2nd hardest material on earth. 2nd only to industrial diamonds.



true story.

fatty tua never fought a Klitschko......

[Left Hook Tua]

fatty tua never fought a Klitschko......

yes. the klitschkos were very , very lucky......