De La Hoya , Chavez , Duran , Mosley and Whitaker

[El Dominicano]

it's okay.

i'm gonna nitpick a typo on your next thread. ha ha ha

You'll find alot lol.

[warp1432]

Oscar De La Hoya , Julio Cesar Chavez , [135]Roberto Duran , Shane Mosley and Pernell Whitaker are all very skilled and great fighters.

A Floyd Mayweather Jr. fan just posted on the Kostya Tszyu thread that all those great fighters would "dust" Kostya Tszyu.

He has a good point. Those guys probably could beat Kostya but those guys are all great fighters.

Now at of curiousity , how would those guys do against Floyd Mayweather Jr.?

I'm of the opinion that prime vs. prime all those guys beat Floyd Mayweather Jr. as well.

Thoughts?

The bolded beat him. Oscar has a better chance then Shane.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

There is not a fighter who has been born who wouldn't knock Floyd on his ducking, cowardly ass.

[poeticlsykuac]

If Mosley fought Mayweather at 135 I think that would be interesting. Mosley was a monster at 135, a scary fighter 31-0 29 KOs. His speed, strength, agility, and power could disassemble Mayweather, Castillo came at Mayweather at 135. I'd say Mosley ups Castillo in every department including chin, he moved all the way to 154 and never got KO'd.

So if we are talking prime Mosley his best years were at 135. Not to say he didn't have a great career at 147.

[Left Hook Tua]

There is not a fighter who has been born who wouldn't knock Floyd on his ducking, cowardly ass.

ahh.........

reverse psychology. very smart , mr. dominican god.

[Left Hook Tua]

The bolded beat him. Oscar has a better chance then Shane.

interesting.

i think the opposite though.

i think the shane mosley at 135 before bulking up slowed him down would do better than oscar against floyd.

mosley-floyd at 135 would've been incredible. too bad shane moved to 147 for the big payday with oscar.

[Brockton Lip]

Prime for prime, Mayweather possibly loses to all of them although he may be able to beat Chavez.

[warp1432]

interesting.

i think the opposite though.

i think the shane mosley at 135 before bulking up slowed him down would do better than oscar against floyd.

mosley-floyd at 135 would've been incredible. too bad shane moved to 147 for the big payday with oscar.

I don't know, maybe because I just rewatched Forrest-Mosley 1 today is why, but Shane was took vicious rights, uppercuts, body shots, etc from Forrest and I think Floyd could land them as well, especially the right.

[Left Hook Tua]

Prime for prime, Mayweather possibly loses to all of them although he may be able to beat Chavez.

that's how i feel too.

floyd is a bad matchup for julio. too much speed......but you never know chavez was one tough mofo.

[poeticlsykuac]

interesting.

i think the opposite though.

i think the shane mosley at 135 before bulking up slowed him down would do better than oscar against floyd.

mosley-floyd at 135 would've been incredible. too bad shane moved to 147 for the big payday with oscar.

Agreed said it in my post a few minutes ago, I would actually favor Mosley at 135.