De La Hoya , Chavez , Duran , Mosley and Whitaker

[Left Hook Tua]

I honestly think prime for prime they all beat him.

especially if we go with those guys prime weights.

oscar at 147 , duran at 135 , chavez at 140 etc.

[Boofdatruth]

The only fighter that I think beats Floyd is Prime Duran. Floyd was capable of beating the other guys.

[Left Hook Tua]

Nope, Floyd's at his best at 130. He's great at 135 and really good at 140 as well, but he's the best at 130.

i said he was at his best at 130 and 135.

140 is what's is more natural for his body. it wasn't really healthy for him to stay at 130 and i don't think he's really a 147 lb. guy.

[El Dominicano]

Oscar De La Hoya , Julio Cesar Chavez , Roberto Duran , Shane Mosley and Pernell Whitaker are all very skilled and great fighters.

A Floyd Mayweather Jr. fan just posted on the Kostya Tszyu thread that all those great fighters would "dust" Kostya Tszyu.

He has a good point. Those guys probably could beat Kostya but those guys are all great fighters.

Now at of curiousity , how would those guys do against Floyd Mayweather Jr.?

I'm of the opinion that prime vs. prime all those guys beat Floyd Mayweather Jr. as well.

Thoughts?

I would have vote if you put Could instead of would.

[Left Hook Tua]

The only fighter that I think beats Floyd is Prime Duran. Floyd was capable of beating the other guys.

capable. of course he is. floyd is very skilled and capable of beating a lot of people.

but i'm talking about if you had to bet your money on it.

i think shane was spectacular at 135. floyd is a bad matchup for chavez. the prime , young 147 oscar would do much better against floyd than the recent outing.

[Left Hook Tua]

I would have vote if you put Could instead of would.

yeah i probably should have put could. sounds better than would.

could implies a capability of doing so. would implies it's a definite outcome.

my bad.

[KostyaTszyu44]

at lightweight prime duran and mosley are too aggressive and too strong for floyd IMO and would win a UD...at welterweight a prime oscar vs mayweather at welterweight i still think floyd would get a SD, even though he only beat an old oscar by SD i dont think floyd took it out of 2nd gear in that fight and if he was at his best he would SD a prime oscar.....

i think floyd would UD chavez at 140, and floyd vs sweet pea is a tough fight.....i think it could end up a draw or maybe an SD for floyd

[El Dominicano]

especially if we go with those guys prime weights.

oscar at 147 , duran at 135 , chavez at 140 etc.

Mayweather beats Chavez at 140.
Mayweather best weight is 130/135 its a toss up between Duran and Mayweather. Duran in my opinion was the greatest Infighter.
Mayweather beats DLH at 147.

[El Dominicano]

yeah i probably should have put could. sounds better than would.

could implies a capability of doing so. would implies it's a definite outcome.

my bad.

No big deal.

[Left Hook Tua]

No big deal.

it's okay.

i'm gonna nitpick a typo on your next thread. ha ha ha