David Haye vs James Toney.....who wins?

[KostyaTszyu44]

haye by UD....i stand by my claim no one wil ever stop james toney

[Clegg]

Haye was supposed to fight Rahman if he beat Toney, so maybe now Haye-Toney will happen instead. I would like to know who Wlad Owns would pick to win, considering how much he seems to hate both of them.

haye was in trouble against a shot mormeck (who himself started at light heavy)
haye has shown he has trouble against short stocky fighters (fragomeni and mormeck)

Eh? What trouble did Haye have against Fragomeni? Haye dominated and then stopped him.

And Mormeck isn't shot either...

[duffgun]

Haye late KO

[Left Hook Tua]

James Toney is still a big name. It's a good move for Haye who might want to get some exposure and also test the waters before going up against the bigger hitting HW's.

have to agree though i'm a big toney fan as well.

his skills get him by but he has to fight in spurts.

i doubt he can ko haye and haye is young and strong.

toney does better against old guys who can't fight a full round or younger guys that are slow.

that's why i'd like to see toney-tua. they'd take turns and each have their moments against each other but against young guys that are busy , tua and toney would have their problems. though tua's power might let him get "lucky" against haye i doubt toney has the power to ko haye wth a single punch.

and how come there's no poll?

[kadyo's]

This will be a good match up. I would want to see how toney would react to david's heavy punches. Will toney, despite his age, be still slick enough to beat a young fighter like haye?

[Joe2608]

Toney wouldn't have a chance if it wasn't for his solid chin. So Haye by late KO.

[NextGeneration]

toney ud, people massively overrate haye

[Flab]

Haye is fighting top 10 heavys. If he doesn't then he's going to fight at least a top 50 one.

James Toney is a 10 ten heavyweight?

[Flab]

have to agree though i'm a big toney fan as well.

his skills get him by but he has to fight in spurts.

i doubt he can ko haye and haye is young and strong.

toney does better against old guys who can't fight a full round or younger guys that are slow.

that's why i'd like to see toney-tua. they'd take turns and each have their moments against each other but against young guys that are busy , tua and toney would have their problems. though tua's power might let him get "lucky" against haye i doubt toney has the power to ko haye wth a single punch.

and how come there's no poll?

Toney would KO Haye. Haye would tire himself out trying to KO Toney and would end up getting massacred in the 5th or 6th round.

[Left Hook Tua]

Toney would KO Haye. Haye would tire himself out trying to KO Toney and would end up getting massacred in the 5th or 6th round.

you say that in jest , right?

when was the last time toney koed a heavyweight?

you're from hertfordshire for god's sake.