Whos Accomplished more in boxing? Pavlik or Kessler?

[abadger]

Come on dude you cannot be serious. I'm not flaming but Kessler's biggest win is ****ing Mundine.

I think Pavliks defeat of Taylorr is overrated. I don't rate Taylor. I think Kessler's opposition is underrated.

[Chunk..]

I'll say pavlik but only because his '0' is still intact. But when it's all said and done, Kessler beats any form of Pavlik at 168. Kessler is a monster at SMW.

[MELLY-MEL...]

I think Pavliks defeat of Taylorr is overrated. I don't rate Taylor. I think Kessler's opposition is underrated.

than i hope you don't rate joes win over bhop at all, because taylor looked better against a younger bhop than joe did!

[Dan...]

I think Pavliks defeat of Taylorr is overrated. I don't rate Taylor. I think Kessler's opposition is underrated.

I respectfully disagree with you. I do not rate Beyer and Mundine is hardly a world-beater. Taylor easily trumps both those wins IMO.

[The Critic]

Kessler is clearly the better fighter.

[abadger]

than i hope you don't rate joes win over bhop at all, because taylor looked better against a younger bhop than joe did!

Boxing doesn't work like that though, does it, and besides, Taylor didn't look better than Calzaghe against Hopkins.

As it happens I don't rate Calzaghe's win over Hopkins that highly, its an excellent win, don't get me wrong, but i knew he would beat him, whereas I wasn't at all sure before the Kessler fight.

[slicksouthpaw16]

Kessler is clearly the better fighter.

They said the same thing about Taylor before he fought Pavlik.

[MELLY-MEL...]

Boxing doesn't work like that though, does it, and besides, Taylor didn't look better than Calzaghe against Hopkins.

As it happens I don't rate Calzaghe's win over Hopkins that highly, its an excellent win, don't get me wrong, but i knew he would beat him, whereas I wasn't at all sure before the Kessler fight.

taylor is so underrated it's unreal. the kid can fight. 2 wins vs bhop and a draw with winky, both atg's is enough to prove he is legit! he was on the p4p list, and the mw champion of the world. he ended bhops defense streak. if thats not a very good fighter, and a credible win to beat him, i can't say anymore!

[slicksouthpaw16]

Boxing doesn't work like that though, does it, and besides, Taylor didn't look better than Calzaghe against Hopkins.

As it happens I don't rate Calzaghe's win over Hopkins that highly, its an excellent win, don't get me wrong, but i knew he would beat him, whereas I wasn't at all sure before the Kessler fight.

Hopkins was more closer to his prime when Taylor beat him. Taylor also wasn't knocked down against Hopkins, unlike Calzaghe. Jermain won a unanimous decision the second time and it was for the undisputed middleweight crown.

[Dan...]

LOL at the poll results by the way.