Should there be a Shane Mosley/Cotto Rematch?

[Pugilistic™]

I don't see why not.

[p4pkingfloyd]

no........................................

[oldgringo]

He needs to post a couple of decent wins in the mean time but I don't see why they couldn't have another fight early next year. The first fight was close and Mosley is still a quality fighter.

I'd like to see Cotto take on a guy like Williams at the end of this year. Maybe a Cotto/Williams - Mosley/Clottey card with the winners facing off in '09 to settle the Welterweight division once and for all.

[mspiegelo]

He needs to post a couple of decent wins in the mean time but I don't see why they couldn't have another fight early next year. The first fight was close and Mosley is still a quality fighter.

I'd like to see Cotto take on a guy like Williams at the end of this year. Maybe a Cotto/Williams - Mosley/Clottey card with the winners facing off in '09 to settle the Welterweight division once and for all.

Not a bad idea, but aren't we counting Mr. Judah out a little too early?!? It should be a tough fight for Zab, but I think he has a good shot at winning...

[120]

cotto needs to win this upcoming fight and call mayweather out. I don't see anything else he needs to do. After that win or loose then he can go back and fight the rest of the welterweight crop...

[boxaholic]

he needs to earn it, there would be no gain for him to beat him again unless he gets a title. Therefor no, he doesn't deserve a rematch.

Agreed. You don't earn another title shot by being inactive. Even though Shane deserves by not ducking anybody. He is a class act but he needs to beat a top welter like Clottey or Williams first.

[oldgringo]

Not a bad idea, but aren't we counting Mr. Judah out a little too early?!? It should be a tough fight for Zab, but I think he has a good shot at winning...

More wishful thinking than anything.

Judah has a shot for sure. I have never been completely sold on Clottey. I suspect he's a front runner who will never quite beat the very best fighters in a division. Funny because that can be said about Judah too, although Judah actually notched a quality win over Spinks. If Judah can establish his power early he has a shot to hang on for a decision. I don't see either guy being knocked out, but I favor Clottey by decision.