Lightweight or Welterweight?

[RisAri0]

as a boxing fan, out of these 2 divisions which do u find more exciting right now?... its a toss up for me, so many great possible fights...

[{}MATADOR{}]

as A Boxing Fan, Out Of These 2 Divisions Which Do U Find More Exciting Right Now?... Its A Toss Up For Me, So Many Great Possible Fights...

Welterweight!!!!

[dr.archives]

Man that's a tough call, I'd say it's pretty much even.

[mspiegelo]

its a toss up but i picked 135 to rock the boat and because of pacquiao slightly ****ing up the curve.

The KEY Players (not in any order):

135: Pacman, Campbell, Casa, Valero, JMM, Guzman, Diaz, Katsidis, Amir Khan
147: Cotto, Margarito, Williams, Clottey, Judah, Mosley, Cintron, Collazo, Berto

I realize some good fighters are left off the list, but those are the most serious guys in each division. Anyone feel someone else is more deserving?

[Left Hook Tua]

lightweight is.

manny pacquiao.
joel casamayor.
juan manuel marquez.
nate campbell.
juan diaz.
joan guzman.
edwin valero.
amir khan.
michael katsidis.

[Dan...]

With Floyd, Welterweight. Without him, lightweight.

[Komander]

With Floyd, Welterweight. Without him, lightweight.

I agree as much as some people hate on Floyd he was good for the sport.

[mspiegelo]

lightweight is.

manny pacquiao.
joel casamayor.
juan manuel marquez.
nate campbell.
juan diaz.
joan guzman.
edwin valero.
amir khan.
michael katsidis.

isn't that the same list i have? i said not in any order....

but, if you wanna do it in order i like this:

Manny
JMM/Casa (too close to tell- lets find out in sept)
Guzman (sorry nate, i love ya bro)
nate
katsidis
diaz
valero
amir kahn

i can't make an educated guess on valero or kan. maybe they belong higher. only time will tell..

[slicksouthpaw16]

Lightweight currently has the better fighters. Guzman, Pacquaio, Marquez, Casmayor, Soto, Diaz, Kadsitas, Kahn, Valero, Cambell ect. There is no comparison. Welterweight is good but they only have Cotto, Mosley, Berto and Margarito there. Lightweight has much more young talent.

[mspiegelo]

With Floyd, Welterweight. Without him, lightweight.

I agree here!