Lightweight or Welterweight?

[Left Hook Tua]

isn't that the same list i have? i said not in any order....

but, if you wanna do it in order i like this:

Manny
JMM/Casa (too close to tell- lets find out in sept)
Guzman (sorry nate, i love ya bro)
nate
katsidis
diaz
valero
amir kahn

i can't make an educated guess on valero or kan. maybe they belong higher. only time will tell..

yes it is.

when i was typing it you haven't posted yours yet so i didn't see it.

thankfully , there's no punishment for duplicitous posts......

[slicksouthpaw16]

Even if Mayweather was there, those big fights wouldn't be made unless he was to fight the best and he was matching himself carefully before he retired. Lightweight would still be the better division IMO.

[mspiegelo]

yes it is.

when i was typing it you haven't posted yours yet so i didn't see it.

thankfully , there's no punishment for duplicitous posts......

haha, there should be! nah, i thought you were responding to me. now i c......

[Scott9945]

With Floyd, Welterweight. Without him, lightweight.

I was just about to say the same thing. Welterweight has an edge in quality. Lightweight has the edge in depth.

[nnamme]

Whether the basis is quality or depth, lightweight is still the better division!

[The Gambler1981]

147 is a good division but without Floyd it loses some luster. 135 is a much deeper division overall now with all the guys comming up from 130 to chase Pacquiao.

[Froch You]

I think Welterweight has the better talent but Lightweight is the more exciting division.

[JOM'S]

things are happening in LW ... jmm-casa, nate-guzman & kat-diaz and still many more crazy a$$ fights after that

welter minus floyd and a "cotto victory over marg" ... will amost settle everything at W...

[nnamme]

things are happening in LW ... jmm-casa, nate-guzman & kat-diaz and still many more crazy a$$ fights after that

welter minus floyd and a "cotto victory over marg" ... will amost settle everything at W...

yeah, minus floyd... plus Cotto's loss! Welterweight will not be exciting anymore!

[Silencers]

Lightweight for me.