Where Does RJ go on the p4p List if he Beats Calzaghe?... Convincingly

[MANGLER]

He gets back a spot in the back half of the top 10. Beatin the #2 guy don't automatically mean he could bypass all the other top 10 guys and take Joe's spot.

[Blayde]

Roy wouldt go anywhere in the P4P lists ... Come on, would that really mean hes that good again? It would kick Calzaghe out of the lists because hes shot or whatever, but it wouldnt give Roy his old reflexes back ...

[bsrizpac]

My assertion is that Roy is shot to **** and should no longer be in the ring.

I never agree with Anorak and this is off topic but yeah, I completely agree with this. Roy should not be fighting.

It's beyond ******. He should have retired after he showed he didn't want it in Tarver 3.

Now that's not to say I won't still watch, but it'll be a big deal if he beats Calzaghe. I don't know where or what that would place him.

As for the point on Tarver, I suppose that could be because of current P4P rankings. Meaning Tarver beat Roy a while back and hasn't done anything recently. I think that would be the logic used by most people to put Roy up there.

[BattlingNelson]

I was wondering where we would put RJ on the p4p list if he outclassed calzaghe and beat him this fall. i currently have calzaghe number 4 on my list, and if he gets beaten i would have to drop him down to around 8-9, with jones one or two places higher than that... if we see RJ like he was in his prime i would put him in the top 5, but i doubt that would happen.

Serious question: How high did Pavlik go when he defeated Taylor?