Where Does RJ go on the p4p List if he Beats Calzaghe?... Convincingly

[hishaam15]

I was wondering where we would put RJ on the p4p list if he outclassed calzaghe and beat him this fall. i currently have calzaghe number 4 on my list, and if he gets beaten i would have to drop him down to around 8-9, with jones one or two places higher than that... if we see RJ like he was in his prime i would put him in the top 5, but i doubt that would happen.

[Pugilistic™]

5, 6 or 7.

[Duke McKenzie_]

So where would that place Tarver?

[emurgencee]

yep, 5-7. or where ever joe calzaghe is rated at.

[THE REED]

So where would that place Tarver?

tarver just beat clinton woods... tarver doesnt get placement...

[Jim Jeffries]

So where would that place Tarver?

Below Hopkins.

[Duke McKenzie_]

tarver just beat clinton woods... tarver doesnt get placement...

This is the problem with P4P .... either it's achievement orientated or it's hypothetical.

If Roy Jones got back in the top ten P4P then logically Tarver should be too, seeing as every time he and Royston get together he makes Roy do the Disco Duck.

[hishaam15]

This is the problem with P4P .... either it's achievement orientated or it's hypothetical.

If Roy Jones got back in the top ten P4P then logically Tarver should be too, seeing as every time he and Royston get together he makes Roy do the Disco Duck.

lol if your theory worked like that then we should put Eric Harding even higher than both of them, and RJ above Harding, then Tarver above RJ? it doesnt work like that LOL.

[Duke McKenzie_]

lol if your theory worked like that then we should put Eric Harding even higher than both of them, and RJ above Harding, then Tarver above RJ? it doesnt work like that LOL.

I know it doesn't QUITE, but I'm pointing out how fundamentally flawed the whole thing is.


Reed, tell me the difference between these two videos... in fact, no, **** it, I'll make a thread on it.

[THE REED]

This is the problem with P4P .... either it's achievement orientated or it's hypothetical.

If Roy Jones got back in the top ten P4P then logically Tarver should be too, seeing as every time he and Royston get together he makes Roy do the Disco Duck.

Well believe it or not... its not 2004... tarver just beat clinton woods wh oisnt in the top 25.... and if roy were to beat joe, whose #2... it would mean a lot more than tarver has done