If Mayweather was still active, would Pacman win over Diaz cause him to overtake PBF

[Flawless]

I thought pacman was favourite to win the fight quite easy. But did that win deserve to overtake PBF as P4P Best.

Discuss

[2quick2slick]

With Floyd's inactivity this year?... OFCOURSE!

[Flawless]

NO, let’s say Mayweather was preparing for De La Hoya fight while Pacman knocked out Diaz. Would that win cause him to overtake PBF over as P4P Best??

[Fox McCloud]

I said yes...

Winning a title at lightweight was incredible considering he started at junior flyweight, and won his first title at flyweight.

Floyd's inactivity hurts him quite a bit too.

[Fox McCloud]

NO, let’s say Mayweather was preparing for De La Hoya fight while Pacman knocked out Diaz. Would that win cause him to overtake PBF over as P4P Best??

I'd say yes... that rematch is so pointless (considering the other great opportunities out there), that I think Pacquiao would gain enough ground to overtake Floyd, even if they both win.

[Dan...]

If Floyd was still active, I would still have him at number 1 p4p, with Manny a fairly close second.

[Boofdatruth]

I said yes...

Winning a title at lightweight was incredible considering he started at junior flyweight, and won his first title at flyweight.

Floyd's inactivity hurts him quite a bit too.

Please. He didn't beat Cambpell lol. He beat Diaz. Pac came out of that fight without a scratch.

[2501]

Please. He didn't beat Cambpell lol. He beat Diaz. Pac came out of that fight without a scratch.

kind of like floyd out of the baldomir fight.

[Boofdatruth]

kind of like floyd out of the baldomir fight.

No, Baldy should've had all the titles. The politics of boxing stole 2 of them away and made Cotto, Cargs, and Cintron champs. Williams has the bogus WBO title.

[el malo]

mayweather who?

yes