If Mayweather was still active, would Pacman win over Diaz cause him to overtake PBF

[Winkyftw!]

Pacman looked spectacular, but these p4p lists are really silly. How can you quantify a p4p skill list in any reasonable way? Its impossible.

[wakwak]

no, Im just siding this time with the haters and floyd fans just to be different

[Tha_Greatest]

i didnt have floyd on top to begin with, i had him at 3 and only because he was UNDEFeATED with a nice resume, not great. Floyd now retired as a overpraised undefeated contender top ducker

[My Name Is...]

I say Yes because Mayweather wasnt active enough, while Pac has been busier.

[Kastrioti]

It would be close, but I would pick Pacman, he has been more active than Floyd, he just moved up in weight and got a title, so yea.

[crold1]

I had them tied after JMM II and they still would be. Hatton & DLH >>>>>> Diaz. However, if Pac wins the Lightweight and Jr. Welter titles outright, it would be tough to even take the historical argument of greatness serious. he'd be well in front of Mayweather unless Mayweather came back and did some awesome.

[RisAri0]

all I know is... if Pacquiao were to move up and defeat Hatton and Floyd beat the winner of Cotto/Margarito they would both be co-#1 pound 4 pounders becuz how can u choose that?

[Domain]

yes and the way he won it!

floyd jr rematching oscar would already of knocked him back...I mean first he barely won a SD on oscar! wtf lol

even steve forbes put up more of a fight.

[Easy-E]

Absolutly not.
Anyone who says yes is blatently ignorant on how the p4p system works.
It was David ****ing Diaz!
Floyd is coming off a knockout win over Ricky Hatton.

There are far too many ****** boxing fans...

[OTSS]

I'd say yes... that rematch is so pointless (considering the other great opportunities out there), that I think Pacquiao would gain enough ground to overtake Floyd, even if they both win.

If the rematch is pointless than so was Pacs fight. Why fight a guy who got a narrow ass decision over a fighter he smashed in three rounds? (I do agree with you tho)