Joe Calzaghe the most overrated boxer in history?

[GodOfWarII]

People wouldn't be so pissed if Calzaghe didn't say he was going to fight Jones Jr and retire, but he did. That is the ****tiest win to retire to, and no one will be impressed when he beats Roy Jones Jr. I'd be more impressed if he ko'd roy in the first round.

[Drunk Punch]

People wouldn't be so pissed if Calzaghe didn't say he was going to fight Jones Jr and retire, but he did. That is the ****tiest win to retire to, and no one will be impressed when he beats Roy Jones Jr. I'd be more impressed if he ko'd roy in the first round.

So if Calzaghe changed his mind, decided to fight Pavlik and beat him convincingly like Lacy and Kessler, would you still be calling him overrated?

[GodOfWarII]

So if Calzaghe changed his mind, decided to fight Pavlik and beat him convincingly like Lacy and Kessler, would you still be calling him overrated?

How can anyone call Calzaghe overrated if he was able to beat Pavlik? Have you seen what Pavlik has done, and some moronic nutt-huggers compare Pavlik to Lacy? ****ign Pavlik destroys fighters, Lacy has never destroyed the opposition Pavlik has

[Dynamite Kid]

If Hopkins is shot then what condition is Winky Wright in given that he lost to him or Jermain Taylor given that he fought two close fights with him only a few years ago and who you rate highly as it makes Pavlik sound better.

I agree that Pavlik is deserving of a fight with Calzaghe if that's what he wants but Calzaghe also deserves the right to choose the best offer on the table without being accused of ducking.

no to mention Brook down Bronco McKart

[abadger]

no to mention Brook down Bronko McKart

[GodOfWarII]

Will the bandwagon for Calzaghe be around when he retires after beating a shot roy jones jr and probably doesn't even look too impressive at doing it?

[TheManchine]

Will the bandwagon for Calzaghe be around when he retires after beating a shot roy jones jr and probably doesn't even look too impressive at doing it?

i wonder, when he beats roy it will be joe calzaghe top 10 p4p all time, calzaghe has a better legacy than jones and all this kind of ****.

[RichCCFC]

Will the bandwagon for Calzaghe be around when he retires after beating a shot roy jones jr and probably doesn't even look too impressive at doing it?

I'll forgive you if you tell me the chick's name.

[Easy-E]

Kelly Pavlik is far more over-rated. Zertchue is ****, Zungia is old and was never that good. McKart is old and SHOT, and Miranda was never truley world class he is just a powerful and exciting brawler. He gets credit for his two wins over Taylor, which were impressive but Kessler and Hopkins are both better then Taylor at this point.

Right of course, Hopkins is better than Taylor, who he lost to twice consecutivly...

[Dan...]

i wonder, when he beats roy it will be joe calzaghe top 10 p4p all time, calzaghe has a better legacy than jones and all this kind of ****.

That would be out of this world ridiculous. Would never happen though, surely...