Manny’s to Lose: BoxingScene Pound for Pound Top Ten

[Mr. Philadel]

I think Cotto should be at least 3. Other than that I agree with the rest!

[hotshoes]

i think number 10 should be hatton instead of mosley

[crold1]

I just couldn't go with Hatton; Mosley beat Collazo worse and didn't need the ref and bad shoelaces to secure a win over Lazcano.

[Guest]

By Cliff Rold - While still two weeks from the end of the second quarter, the retirement of Floyd Mayweather has led to a deluge of e-mails from BoxingScene readers and other interested parties. The primary question: with Mayweather gone, who’s #1. [details]

I see Danny Williams has been slighted again.

Cliff Roid - that's Beep's real name.

the game at 36, and he regularly talks retirement, but one has to wonder if he’ll be able to resist a big-money fight in 2009 with Kelly Pavlik should he blow by the faded Roy Jones as

[Pullcounter]

By Cliff Rold - While still two weeks from the end of the second quarter, the retirement of Floyd Mayweather has led to a deluge of e-mails from BoxingScene readers and other interested parties. The primary question: with Mayweather gone, who’s #1. [details]

cotto is too far up... a jump from #7 to #4 is too much after a fight with Gomez... atleast wait for cotto to beat margarito before you move him to #4. I think you're jumping the gun.

JMM should be higher up... about #3. p4p he can beat everyone on this list from #3 down. and have very close fights against #1 (of course) and #2.

R-Marquez should be right behind Vasquez.

Winky or Hopkins should be #10 instead of Mosley. Winky beat Mosley and Hopkins had a close fight against Calzaghe.

[The Hammer]

Interesting list. Joe is my choice for #1 but it's close.

It good to see one of my favorite fighters, Cristian Mijares, recognized as #5.

[Vladimir303]

i think number 10 should be hatton instead of mosley

Ricky Hatton barely defeated Collazo while Mosley dominated him for 12 rounds.

Mosley lost by a close decision to Cotto while Ricky got Ko'd caroonishly.


Have I changed your mind?

[kayjay]

Cliff, take some of the midgets off the list already!

How is Vasquez ahead of Cotto and Pavlik?

How is Wlad not among the ten most dominant in his weight division?


I respect your analytical skills, but you need to stop giving this ridiculous preference to men too small to be real athletes.

[crold1]

Kay: I prefer real FIGHTERS so no Wlad. Besides, Heavyweights don't belong on P4P lists; P4P debate exists to weight the world beneath the biggest boys.

[2501]

Ricky Hatton barely defeated Collazo while Mosley dominated him for 12 rounds.

Mosley lost by a close decision to Cotto while Ricky got Ko'd caroonishly.


Have I changed your mind?

rofl ****ing awesome.