Mayweather? Top 50 All Time? NOT SO FAST...

[ANDROID_DOES]

Bravo!

Are you an American?

If so then you are exceptionally wise.

To sum it up an ATG has names on his resume which will stand the test of time.

Take for examply Pacquiao. Beating legends like Morales and Barrera and provided he continues to win against top opposition will solidify his claim as an ATG.

And it doesn't hurt that Muhammad Ali compared himself to Pacquiao.

If you look at it DLH career surpasses Gayweather very easily.

At the very least in DLH's resume there are a lot of HOF and guys which were considered the best.

Although DLH had his defeats those will do very little to hurt his legacy.

And it will be icing on the cake once DLH decides to fight Cotto as his last fight.

dont bash floyd than praise dlh and call him an atg when floyd gave dlh a boxing lesson...not to mention he did for dlh's money, dlh's date, dlh's weight, dlh's gloves, and dlh's preffered size ring and throw in there dlh almost outweighed floyd by 20lbs. get the **** out of here your a ****en moron. You consider dlh all time great and you yell at how you have to beat atg's to be considered one but when floyd beats dlh you down play it. typical hater

[Tha_Greatest]

Bravo!

Are you an American?

If so then you are exceptionally wise.

To sum it up an ATG has names on his resume which will stand the test of time.

Take for examply Pacquiao. Beating legends like Morales and Barrera and provided he continues to win against top opposition will solidify his claim as an ATG.

And it doesn't hurt that Muhammad Ali compared himself to Pacquiao.

If you look at it DLH career surpasses Gayweather very easily.

At the very least in DLH's resume there are a lot of HOF and guys which were considered the best.

Although DLH had his defeats those will do very little to hurt his legacy.

And it will be icing on the cake once DLH decides to fight Cotto as his last fight.

i am american but i think with my brain not my heart and Barrera, Morales, Jones, Hopkins, Trinidads, Lewis, Holyfield, and many other fighers that fought into the 2000 era have done more to establish their legacy than Floyd, Floyd establishes his legacy by being a undefeated American, keyword- American

[Tha_Greatest]

dont bash floyd than praise dlh and call him an atg when floyd gave dlh a boxing lesson...not to mention he did for dlh's money, dlh's date, dlh's weight, dlh's gloves, and dlh's preffered size ring and throw in there dlh almost outweighed floyd by 20lbs. get the **** out of here your a ****en moron. You consider dlh all time great and you yell at how you have to beat atg's to be considered one but when floyd beats dlh you down play it. typical hater

dont get childish and cuss, have a smart discussion without getting sensitive, A Old Oscar lost to a prime Mayweather by split decision which means it wasnt a decisive win for Floyd, old man oscar did good ifor losing if he lost by split decision, Mayweather was the so called #1 p4p and Oscar wasnt even in the top 25 when he fought Mayweather so Floyd struggled against a non top out of prime fighter based on a split decision win

[Easy-E]

Floyd is easily one of the top 50 fighters of all time.
If he had attempted a fight with Williams, Cintrion or Quintiana I cant even imagine the outcry.
Junior Witter or Ricardo Torres?
Spinks who lost to Verno Phillips and Forrest who was decisioned by Sergio Mora?
This writer is a ****ing idiot, and knows absolutly nothing about the sport.

King, you lose alot of credibility posting this article.

[Easy-E]

dont get childish and cuss, have a smart discussion without getting sensitive, A Old Oscar lost to a prime Mayweather by split decision which means it wasnt a decisive win for Floyd, old man oscar did good ifor losing if he lost by split decision, Mayweather was the so called #1 p4p and Oscar wasnt even in the top 25 when he fought Mayweather so Floyd struggled against a non top out of prime fighter based on a split decision win

We both know thats not true, if you watched the fight as a knowledgable fan of boxing it was evident Floyd won and quite decisivly at that.
There is no way you could give 6 rounds to Oscar.
Keep in mind that Floyd moved up 24 pounds from his original weight and that Oscar, although old, looked far better than he did at 31 and 32.

[Jim Jeffries]

I take it you're new to the sport of boxing and to floyd mayweathers career. Once again name the 50 boxers better than him. You do know most experts rate floyd top 5-10 all time right? It's only un-informed, biased fans that don't really know much about boxing or floyd's career that say the things you do. Maybe you should watch mma?

Are you serious? Name me one of these "experts."

Here is ESPN's rankings:

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Muhammad Ali
3. Henry Armstrong
4. Joe Louis
5. Willie Pep
6. Roberto Duran
7. Benny Leonard
8. Jack Johnson
9. Jack Dempsey
10.Sam Langford

You have to go all the way down to 48 on their list to find Floyd.

http://boxing.about.com/od/history/a/50_greatest.htm