Who was the best pound for pound superstar????

[slicksouthpaw16]

Its really hard for me to choose. Whitaker and Mayweather are almost equal in every department and Hopkins is easily the greatest middleweight of this era.

[TheGreatAli]

This is the order

Pernell Whitaker
Shane Mosley
Floyd Mayweather
Bernard Hopkins
Felix Trinidad

[FUC_U_PAYME]

Pernell Whitaker.

[tredh]

From that list I am torn between Whitaker and PBF but I guess I'll go with Whitaker.

[DuttyAlacrity]

Based on that list
Sweet Pea then Floyd

[krispy kreme]

Sugar Shane for me, but everyone on there was a great champion in their prime.

[COMMY]

I think it comes down to Pernel and Tito

[El Jesus]

From that list I am torn between Whitaker and PBF but I guess I'll go with Whitaker.

same here, whitaker fought the best opposition and mayweather is close, both of them moved up in weight and did what they had to do.

[FloydMoneyMay]

Floyd Mayweather, by far.

[JAB5239]

Who was the best fighter when their were in their respective primes? Hopkins, Whitaker, Mosley, Mayweather or Trinidad?

I voted Tito, but Pea was the best fighter. I probably should have read your post before voting.