lets put calzaghe`s victory over roy into context

[TheManchine]

he's talking about RIGHT NOW, would Roy be able to defeat any of those fight NOW as oppose to near his prime.

being honest, i think he would lose to all of them now

[IconBoy]

God would give Wlad a major beating.

[MANGLER]

would roy beat any of these fighters

dawson,tarver,johnson,kessler or even pavlik.

i cant see him beating nay of them

this is just putting it in perspective because im sure some wil make it out like calzaghe beat a prime roy jones.

thats all

Tarver didn't convince me in either of his 2 wins over Roy he was the better man. I'd pick RJ to beat him. Dawson too. Johnson, no. He owned Roy. Kessler? That's a pick em fight to me. Pavlik would KO Roy. And don't get a head of yourself thinkin Joe C will easily win against him either.

[TheManchine]

Tarver didn't convince me in either of his 2 wins over Roy he was the better man. I'd pick RJ to beat him. Dawson too. Johnson, no. He owned Roy. Kessler? That's a pick em fight to me. Pavlik would KO Roy. And don't get a head of yourself thinkin Joe C will easily win against him either.

im basically making this for people like ricky who will problem claim calzaghe is beating a prime roy and going majorly overboard. i dont really mind calzaghe its people like ricky that make me dislike calzaghe.

i think roy was intimidated by tarver, i think kessler would be too strong and active for roy, pavlik is kind of similar to kessler again i think his activity would be too much for roy. i really would give all a chance of knocking roy out

[abadger]

im basically making this for people like ricky who will problem claim calzaghe is beating a prime roy and going majorly overboard. i dont really mind calzaghe its people like ricky that make me dislike calzaghe.

i think roy was intimidated by tarver, i think kessler would be too strong and active for roy, pavlik is kind of similar to kessler again i think his activity would be too much for roy. i really would give all a chance of knocking roy out

I'm not sure what era of these fighters we are debating here, but right now I'm certain that Kessler would KO Roy, and probably if he fought the Roy that Tarver fought.

Prime for prime though Kessler would get killed by Roy. He tends to jump in behind a reaching jab and prime Roy would see it coming a mile away. He'd just jump back and then return fire with a shot of his own, while Kessler was hanging out to dry wondering where Roy had gone.

[TheManchine]

I'm not sure what era of these fighters we are debating here, but right now I'm certain that Kessler would KO Roy, and probably if he fought the Roy that Tarver fought.

Prime for prime though Kessler would get killed by Roy. He tends to jump in behind a reaching jab and prime Roy would see it coming a mile away. He'd just jump back and then return fire with a shot of his own, while Kessler was hanging out to dry wondering where Roy had gone.

im talking about. roy imo would beat them all in his prime

[MELLY-MEL...]

would roy beat any of these fighters

dawson,tarver,johnson,kessler or even pavlik.

i cant see him beating nay of them

this is just putting it in perspective because im sure some wil make it out like calzaghe beat a prime roy jones.

thats all

current roy? i don't think she beats any of them! prime he whoops all, including Joe!