lets put calzaghe`s victory over roy into context

[TheManchine]

would roy beat any of these fighters

dawson,tarver,johnson,kessler or even pavlik.

i cant see him beating nay of them

this is just putting it in perspective because im sure some wil make it out like calzaghe beat a prime roy jones.

thats all

[Sin City]

they haven't even fought yet...

[TheManchine]

they haven't even fought yet...

yes but im so sure calzaghe will win im saying it now

[TheManchine]

bump..............................................

[GodOfWarII]

I'm sure Calzaghe will win a close decision against a shot fighter

[hunter010]

joe would beat tarver , roy already lost to tarver but oh well tarvers a crap fighter

[TheManchine]

joe would beat tarver , roy already lost to tarver but oh well tarvers a crap fighter

thats not what im saying. would roy beat any of the fighters listed?

[Kivian]

thats not what im saying. would roy beat any of the fighters listed?

RJJ already beat Tarver in '03...

[Ryn0]

RJJ already beat Tarver in '03...

he's talking about RIGHT NOW, would Roy be able to defeat any of those fight NOW as oppose to near his prime.

[TheManchine]

RJJ already beat Tarver in '03...

now im talking about right now,