If you thought Castillo beat Mayweather...

[DiegoFuego]

I gave Tarver rounds 2, 7, 8, 10, and 12. Roy got a lot of good work done in round 12, but Tarver had one good rally and landed two clean solid blows right before the bell to edge it

[Boofdatruth]

tarver did all his work in like 3 rounds......castillo was consistent.....

nice try though....
i know everytime the floyd fans watch that fight they delude themselves into thinking "well that punch didnt land that clean" everytime castillo is doing his work...

Floyd beat him twice, and he didn't have to hold and hit and hit low to do it. Only floyd haters keep on crying he lost lol.

[-Hyperion-]

Floyd beat him twice, and he didn't have to hold and hit and hit low to do it. Only floyd haters keep on crying he lost lol.

im not a floyd hater, far from it, but bs needs to be called and he lost the first castillo fight(injured arm, but who cares, it does not excuse getting a gift...)and its not like foyd had a walk in the park in the rematch, a clear 7-5...the judges had it an SD in the rematch...

oh and funny to bring up castillo's fouling...didnt floyd get deducted as much points(1-1) as castillo for fouling???....

[-Hyperion-]

I gave Tarver rounds 2, 7, 8, 10, and 12. Roy got a lot of good work done in round 12, but Tarver had one good rally and landed two clean solid blows right before the bell to edge it

what does "solid" have to do with what.....

its called clean-effective not solid or powerful or hard or whatever some guys like to score...

[DiegoFuego]

what does "solid" have to do with what.....

its called clean-effective not solid or powerful or hard or whatever some guys like to score...

I think you may have just admitted you don't know how to score a fight. This post of yours will be useful when reading your scorecards in the future.

[DiegoFuego]

I would LOVE to see some scorecards from people that claim Castillo won, but they never seem to show up on here. Wonder why.

[Boofdatruth]

im not a floyd hater, far from it, but bs needs to be called and he lost the first castillo fight(injured arm, but who cares, it does not excuse getting a gift...)and its not like foyd had a walk in the park in the rematch, a clear 7-5...the judges had it an SD in the rematch...

oh and funny to bring up castillo's fouling...didnt floyd get deducted as much points(1-1) as castillo for fouling???....

You are giving us totally wrong information.

[johnm is...]

im not a floyd hater, far from it, but bs needs to be called and he lost the first castillo fight(injured arm, but who cares, it does not excuse getting a gift...)and its not like foyd had a walk in the park in the rematch, a clear 7-5...the judges had it an SD in the rematch...

oh and funny to bring up castillo's fouling...didnt floyd get deducted as much points(1-1) as castillo for fouling???....

Floyd won a UD in the rematch.

[slicksouthpaw16]

A fighter can win the rounds by simply throwing punches. I am a fan of both of these fighters so this is not a bias view. It does't matter if the punches are not landing cleanly, the judges are impressed with letting your hands go. Which is why Oscar won as many rounds as he did against Mayweather and why Dawson was awarded the decision against Johnson. Castillio out worked Mayweather IMO and i had him winning 115-113. He was bringing educated pressure and going to the body effectively while Mayweather on the ropes. He also did well at cutting off the ring. I didn't see Jones/Tarver I so i won't comment on that one.