If you thought Castillo beat Mayweather...

[DiegoFuego]

Then Tarver beat Roy in the first fight and much more clearly. Tarver threw and landed more punches (since that's what we base fights on now, right? lol) and actually landed punches you could see on Roy. Castillo landed very few flush punches on Floyd and hardly won any rounds as convincingly as Tarver did against Roy.

For the record, I had it 114-112 Mayweather and 115-113 Jones in those respective fights after my most recent scorings.

[Guest]

You scored an even round in Mayweather-Castillo?

I saw that fight three times... first time I scored for Cast, the second two Floyd.

[2501]

what kind of post pattern would we find if we dig up your old threads?

[DiegoFuego]

what kind of post pattern would we find if we dig up your old threads?

Please do, newcomer.

Anorak, there were two points deducted in that fight, one from each fighter. I had it 7 rounds to 5. I never score even rounds without point deductions of some kind.

[Duke McKenzie_]

Please do, newcomer.

Anorak, there were two points deducted in that fight, one from each fighter. I had it 7 rounds to 5. I never score even rounds without point deductions of some kind.

I think that **** Anorak forgot about that, it's been a while since he saw it.

But he definitely scored it to Floyd the last two times he watched it.

[Boofdatruth]

Then Tarver beat Roy in the first fight and much more clearly. Tarver threw and landed more punches (since that's what we base fights on now, right? lol) and actually landed punches you could see on Roy. Castillo landed very few flush punches on Floyd and hardly won any rounds as convincingly as Tarver did against Roy.

For the record, I had it 114-112 Mayweather and 115-113 Jones in those respective fights after my most recent scorings.

Exactly. You have to beat a fighter legally. and if the public somehow comes to the conclusion that a fighter loss, you fight a rematch. Tarver won the second and third fights, and floyd won the rematch. Good post.

[C'MONMANG']

Then Tarver beat Roy in the first fight and much more clearly. Tarver threw and landed more punches (since that's what we base fights on now, right? lol) and actually landed punches you could see on Roy. Castillo landed very few flush punches on Floyd and hardly won any rounds as convincingly as Tarver did against Roy.

For the record, I had it 114-112 Mayweather and 115-113 Jones in those respective fights after my most recent scorings.

wow, you are a smarty.

lotta people had Tarver beating Roy.

[superchamp]

Exactly. You have to beat a fighter legally. and if the public somehow comes to the conclusion that a fighter loss, you fight a rematch. Tarver won the second and third fights, and floyd won the rematch. Good post.

The problem with the Jones-Tarver I is that Roy outlanded Tarver in the majority of the rounds, and landed more power shots in 9 of 12 rounds.

Tarver did all of his work in 3 or 4 rounds, and did nothing in rounds 3-7, where Jones controlled the action by deterring him with right hands to the body.

Then Roy clearly won rounds 9, 11 and 12.

Jones clearly took 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 11, 12.

Tarver took 1, 2, 8 and 10.

Rounds 1 and 7 were fairly close and an argument could be made that they could have gone either way, but under no scenerio did Tarver win enough rounds to win that fight.

[-Hyperion-]

tarver did all his work in like 3 rounds......castillo was consistent.....

nice try though....
i know everytime the floyd fans watch that fight they delude themselves into thinking "well that punch didnt land that clean" everytime castillo is doing his work...

[xcaret]

tarver did all his work in like 3 rounds......castillo was consistent.....

nice try though....
i know everytime the floyd fans watch that fight they delude themselves into thinking "well that punch didnt land that clean" everytime castillo is doing his work...

hows the sig looking?