I just watched Z Gorres vs Fernando Montiel...

[warp1432]

How and the HELL was that considered a robbery

My scorecard was 116-111 because I had it 8-3-1 for Montiel. I only gave Gorres rounds 2,5,8 and round 9 was even. You have the 2 point deductions so normally it would be 117-109 or 116-110 whoever you gave round 9 to, but still how the hell do people consider that a robbery. Montiel pretty much busted him up and was blocking most of Gorres punches with his gloves. He also threw the way better punches.

Though after watching this fight, Castillo, and Maldanado, I've come to the terms that Montiel would not beat Mijares. Not even close. He's way to slow on foot, Gorres' jab was giving him major problems. Mijares has a big height advantage. Montiel also leaps foward with his punches that basically screams "Hit me in the face please. I'm wide open"

Montiel has good handspeed on the inside, but Mijares constantly moving and throwing 1-2's in his face and not being in the pocket too often (though Gorres did somewhat fine in there) would give Montiel major hell and he'd lose a wide UD.

I think he might be able to beat Donaire though. Donaire doesn't have nearly as good as a jab. He has good defense for blocking hooks and if Montiel keeps plotting foward he might get to him. He wouldn't get to Mijares though.

Overall, I can't believe this was even called a close decision let alone a robbery. Montiel clearly won.

[warp1432]

Bump for Lou

[loui_ludwig]

Bump for Lou

Oh, thank you. Your such a "true boxing fan", unlike those Ring mag, Boxing Monthly, and other boxing medias.

And its nice of you to be Xcarets friend.

[warp1432]

Alright then, you said you gave 8 rounds to Gorres? What rounds are those because please I'm dying to know when Gorres was eating a lot of leather and Montiel was blocking a lot of Gorres' shots with his gloves. If Gorres actually threw down the middle a lot more he probably would have won. Montiel can't take shots down the middle for ****.

[delipooke]

Well, this thread reeks more of Warp ****sucking mijares than what the title of the thread says. What it is about Montiel/donaire that scares you warp?

[xcaret]

Oh, thank you. Your such a "true boxing fan", unlike those Ring mag, Boxing Monthly, and other boxing medias.

And its nice of you to be Xcarets friend.

you cant stop with the same ****, instead of arguing what rounds you gave to Gorres you come up with the same bull**** that the "ring magazine had gorres winning"... shut the **** up, Montiel whooped that ass and is gonna knock him the **** out in the rematch...

[warp1432]

Well, this thread reeks more of Warp ****sucking mijares than what the title of the thread says. What it is about Montiel/donaire that scares you warp?

At least I bother to give an explanation on why I picked Mijares over Montiel. Most people are just like "HE'S GOING TO KICK HIS ASS!!" and then don't even bother explaining why.

As for Donaire, Donaire would be pretty competitive with Mijares, but I feel he would lose a clear decision to him. Donaire has a good shot of beating Montiel too. I can see Montiel beating him (read above why), but I think I would take Donaire. I like Donaire. He's a good fighter.

[loui_ludwig]

Alright then, you said you gave 8 rounds to Gorres? What rounds are those because please I'm dying to know when Gorres was eating a lot of leather and Montiel was blocking a lot of Gorres' shots with his gloves. If Gorres actually threw down the middle a lot more he probably would have won. Montiel can't take shots down the middle for ****.

Have seen the fight twice and it was last year. When i said 8 rounds, its what the Ring mag have, not mine. I do have Z wnning 7 rounds, not sure of exact rounds. I don't remember if i said 8. But you like to use the search function, why don't you look for my posts about it.

[KILLA RIGHT]

Montiel won that fight i dont see a possibility of robbery

[warp1432]

Even then I don't see how you could give Gorres any rounds other then 2,5,8 and possibly round 9.