How would Calzaghe had fared had he faced legit comp rather then bums???

[KnockoutTheFat]

Jones Jr. L UD

Trinidad W UD or late TKO

Hopkins( a younger version) L UD

Winky dunno could go either way actually

James Toney L close decision

Glen Johnson W MD

Jermaine Taylor W UD

Chad Dawson W UD

Kelly Pavlik W UD

Antonio Tarver DRAW

[Benn_Foust]

This board seems to be anti-Calzaghe and I think that's down the the fact he's British.

I'm a big Hopkins fan and I think he lost the fight to Joe by 4-5 rounds, it really wasn't as competitive as some people think or try to make out. If you think about it, Floyd Mayweather only defeated Oscar De La Hoya by SD yet he doesn't have people constantly ****ing on about how a younger Oscar beats him.

Just an observation.

[DeepSleep]

Jones Jr. - L by Wide UD

Trinidad - Win By KO

Hopkins( a younger version) - L by UD

Winky - Win by UD

James Toney - L by a close UD

Glen Johnson - Win UD

Jermaine Taylor - Win by KO

Chad Dawson - Haven't seen enough from Dawson yet

Kelly Pavlik - Win UD

Antonio Tarver - Win UD

Imo...

[Vasyl’s dad]

How would he had done against:::

Jones Jr.

Trinidad

Hopkins( a younger version)

Winky

James Toney

Glen Johnson

Jermaine Taylor

Chad Dawson

Kelly Pavlik

Antonio Tarver



??????????????????????????????????????????

He'd do as good as Floyd versus Cotto, Margarito, Mosley, Williams, Forrest, Mayorga, etc.

[daggum]

This board seems to be anti-Calzaghe and I think that's down the the fact he's British.

I'm a big Hopkins fan and I think he lost the fight to Joe by 4-5 rounds, it really wasn't as competitive as some people think or try to make out. If you think about it, Floyd Mayweather only defeated Oscar De La Hoya by SD yet he doesn't have people constantly ****ing on about how a younger Oscar beats him.

Just an observation.

hello brit!

[SkillspayBills]

Jones Jr. Lose

Trinidad Win

Hopkins( a younger version) Tossup

Winky Win

James Toney Lose

Glen Johnson Win

Jermaine Taylor Win

Chad Dawson Win

Kelly Pavlik Win

Antonio Tarver Win