How would Calzaghe had fared had he faced legit comp rather then bums???

[Burner]

How would he had done against:::

Jones Jr.

Trinidad

Hopkins( a younger version)

Winky

James Toney

Glen Johnson

Jermaine Taylor

Chad Dawson

Kelly Pavlik

Antonio Tarver



??????????????????????????????????????????

[Burner]

do drop by to www.shop-foco.com look through the articles there. With information on anything from getting the cheapest shoes
welcome website: www.shop-foco.com ,there are are have many cheap products

Get a real job.

[hunter010]

he beats them all KO round 1.

[COLINSRI]

Jones or Toney on the 'gear' would have bashed JC but then they really should not have licences for what they have done. JC 'could' beat all n that list, provided it ws not a yank ref.

[ИATAS]

Jones Jr. LOSE

Trinidad WIN

Hopkins( a younger version) LOSE

Winky LOSE

James Toney LOSE

Glen Johnson WIN

Jermaine Taylor WIN

Chad Dawson WIN

Kelly Pavlik LOSE

Antonio Tarver LOSE (p4p)

[Burner]

Jones Jr. LOSE

Trinidad WIN

Hopkins( a younger version) LOSE

Winky LOSE

James Toney LOSE

Glen Johnson WIN

Jermaine Taylor WIN

Chad Dawson WIN

Kelly Pavlik LOSE

Antonio Tarver LOSE (p4p)

I have the exact same results...except for the Dawson fight..I think Chad has the goods to beat Calzaghe...but Calzaghe would beat Trinidad with ease.

[MANGLER]

[QUOTE=Burner;3571519]How would he had done against:::

Jones Jr. - lose UD

Trinidad - win UD

Hopkins( a younger version)- lose KO

Winky - lose UD

James Toney - lose UD

Glen Johnson - win UD

Jermaine Taylor - win UD

Chad Dawson - Win KO

Kelly Pavlik - win UD

Antonio Tarver - win KO

All these fights coulda been entertaining tho.

[ИATAS]

I have the exact same results...except for the Dawson fight..I think Chad has the goods to beat Calzaghe...but Calzaghe would beat Trinidad with ease.

I'm a lil uncertain about Chad. Could go either way but I need to see more from him, he's a young guy and just had a real tough fight against Johnson, which I had Johnson winning, so jury is still out. Then again, I think Johnson was landing much harder shots on Dawson then Calzaghe ever could, so I dunno.

[Benn_Foust]

Jones Jr. L

Trinidad W

Hopkins( a younger version) W

Winky W

James Toney Hard to choose, probably W

Glen Johnson W

Jermaine Taylor W

Chad Dawson W

Kelly Pavlik W

Antonio Tarver W


As a boxer myself I appreciate all the little things Joe does in a fight and I think out of that list only Roy Jones and James Toney (possibly) have more natural talent than Calzaghe does.

[abadger]

How would he had done against:::

Jones Jr.

Trinidad

Hopkins( a younger version)

Winky

James Toney

Glen Johnson

Jermaine Taylor

Chad Dawson

Kelly Pavlik

Antonio Tarver



??????????????????????????????????????????

Calzaghe would have beaten everybody on the list with the possible exception of Jones. After that the toughest fights he COULD lose would be Hopkins, Toney, Tarver and right now Chad Dawson.

However, this list is not very realistic as Winky and Trinidad were weightclasses below him in their prime, Toney a cruiserweight and Dawson and Pavlik are fights that could only conceivably happen more or less now. Glen Johnson was a poor SMW in the 90s only emerging as elite after beating a shot Roy Jones at light heavy, Tarver also only really emerged onto the big stage at this time too. Hopkins could have fought Joe in 2001 put priced himself out. Very few of these fights could ever really have happened before about 2003 and some of them not at all.