who would win a Margarito v Paul Williams rematch?

[abadger]

i take it u have never seen Rafael Marquez v Israel Vasquez 1,2,3

man u dont know what u are missing 3 of the best fights since Corrales v Castillo 1 ,the 3rd is a complete war ,great fight

Nope. They go to the top of the list. Thanks a lot man.

[Dynamite Kid]

Nope. They go to the top of the list. Thanks a lot man.

BTW i think the second fight was voted FOTY

[Haglerwins]

Better performances from both - Same result

I would really like to see Marg win the rematch, but Paul knows how to box out of the break really well against a come forward guy like that. Anywho, Marg instead goes for walking through Williams shots instead of trying to parry everything, and Paul boxes out of the break more to create separation and stunt Tony's body attack. It becomes bad to watch when Williams starts holding excessively and ends up doing it more than in the first fight, but it works in his advantage as it assists him in dishing out that high work rate that puts him over the top in the same fashion. 7-5 Punisher.