Was Floyd's win over Castillo bigger than Zaghe's win over Lacy?

[Addition]

Calzaghe seems to be flavour of the month at the moment.

[pesticid]

At the time? Lacy, easily.

Now that we have seen after a few more fights what Castillo did at 135, and what Lacy has done/looks like he is going to do at 168, Castillo gets the nod easily.

Have you seen the streak of fighters that Castillo beat after Floyd left?

I am speaking at the time.

Besides Floyd didn't administer a frightful beating on Castillo like Calzaghe did on lacy.

[Dirt E Gomez]

But those 3 were all title bouts.

Grasping at straws much?

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Castillo: borderline great fighter. Best at his division for years.

Lacy: vastly overrated fighter who never accomplished anything.

Hmmmmmmm?

[Fox McCloud]

I am speaking at the time.

Besides Floyd didn't administer a frightful beating on Castillo like Calzaghe did on lacy.

Of course... Why do you even make these ****ing polls if you set stipulations so Calzaghe should get every vote? An unknown Castillo at the time who broke out and did great things after Floyd fought him, or the ultimate hypejob Lacy who has since struggled with terrible fighters.

Well, I think discussing how the fighters did after their respective fights would hurt my case that Calzaghe is better than Mayweather, so we will just throw that out.

Castillo: borderline great fighter. Best at his division for years.

Lacy: vastly overrated fighter who never accomplished anything.

Hmmmmmmm?

UHHHH DUDE! IT'S AT THE TIME THAT THEY FOUGHT! GET IT RIGHT!

What a ****** ****ing poll.

[MANGLER]

Pbf's 1st win over Castillo was too debatable. Joe C over Lacy was arguably the worst ass whoopin ever in a prizefight.

[pesticid]

Castillo didn't even lose the first one and he had 4 tko losses on his ledger. Damn!

[Fox McCloud]

Castillo didn't even lose the first one and he had 4 tko losses on his ledger. Damn!

Okay champ, why don't you outline the circumstances of all four of those TKO losses. They all are the same type of TKO loss, so please, enlighten us.

[pesticid]

Okay champ, why don't you outline the circumstances of all four of those TKO losses. They all are the same type of TKO loss, so please, enlighten us.

4 tkos, enlightened yet?

[Kball15]

OF COARSE!!!

Castillo is a TRULY GREAT Lightweight champion, undeniable.

LACY was an overrated supermiddleweight that never was anybody and never will be.

Jesus, some people.

Mayweathers win over Castillo was SOOOOOOOO much bigger then Calzaghe's win over Lacy. Was Calzaghes performance better? Yea, but he was fighting half the fighter