Was Floyd's win over Castillo bigger than Zaghe's win over Lacy?

[pesticid]

Floyd was the favourite, Castillo had the WBC title.
Lacy was the favourite, he had the IBF and WBO titles.

Lacy was undefeated at the time while Castillo had a draw and a split decision victory over Stevie Johnston and 4 tko losses.

Floyd won a very controversial fight, in my eyes he lost.
Calzaghe won every second of every round against "The Next Mike Tyson"

[RichCCFC]

NO CHANCE. Floyd lost to a guy who was knocked out 4 times before they fought.

[Sin City]

Mayweather didn't win that fight..

[RichCCFC]

Mayweather didn't win that fight..

Another poll to come.

[pesticid]

Another poll to come.

Good one!

[Dorian]

will u stop with these threads jk

[Dirt E Gomez]

Enough with the ****** ****ing threads. Seriously.

If the point you're going to try to make by listing 3-4 fights from Calzaghe and comparing them to Floyd, the problem is you can then list many more for Floyd after those and just absolutely trounce Zag's.

[pesticid]

Enough with the ****** ****ing threads. Seriously.

If the point you're going to try to make by listing 3-4 fights from Calzaghe and comparing them to Floyd, the problem is you can then list many more for Floyd after those and just absolutely trounce Zag's.

But those 3 were all title bouts.

[Fox McCloud]

At the time? Lacy, easily.

Now that we have seen after a few more fights what Castillo did at 135, and what Lacy has done/looks like he is going to do at 168, Castillo gets the nod easily.

Have you seen the streak of fighters that Castillo beat after Floyd left?

[RichCCFC]

But Floyd didn't beat Castillo, he lost.

This is a trick question.