Is Calzaghe a Top 25 Fighter in the last 30 Years?

[Vigilant3]

Castillo actually won the first fight against Mayweather -- that was a gimme.

[Clegg]

How many rounds did you score for Reid? Please let me know which ones you scored for him, cheers.

I'm uploading the fight on youtube so people who havent watched it (mostly americans) can watch calzaghe's first loss

Round 1: Reid
Round 2: Calzaghe
Round 3: Calzaghe
Round 4: Calzaghe
Round 5: Reid
Round 6: Reid
Round 7: Even
Round 8: Calzaghe
Round 9: Reid
Round 10: Reid
Round 11: Calzaghe
Round 12: Even

5 rounds each, 2 even, and a point taken away from Reid in the 8th.

115-114 Calzaghe

[Equilibrium]

I can't beleive all the flagrant racism in this thread.

I voted no. I do consider Calzaghe a good fighter and i think he sure has the potential to be in that list, but right now he isn't. He has a couple of years of fighting left so we will see. Who he fights in the future and how he does could change my, and everybody else's opinion.

[Silencers]

I had Calzaghe beating Reid 115-112, 7-5 in rounds with 1 point deducted from Reid.

[COLINSRI]

Calzaghe is definately in the top 30. For those who think he is not "there are none so blind as those who refuse to see".

He has a classy reume which would be much better if all the yank SMW were not too scared to come to UK to face him.

He smashed hopkins who ran and ran and ran

[IMDAZED]

Calzaghe is definately in the top 30. For those who think he is not "there are none so blind as those who refuse to see".

He has a classy reume which would be much better if all the yank SMW were not too scared to come to UK to face him.

He smashed hopkins who ran and ran and ran

Top 25 of the last THIRTY years? Get serious...

And why would the "yank SMW's" go to the UK to fight him? Tell me...why in the world would, Roy Jones, for instance, want to do that in 2000?

[bsrizpac]

I can't beleive all the flagrant racism in this thread.

I voted no. I do consider Calzaghe a good fighter and i think he sure has the potential to be in that list, but right now he isn't. He has a couple of years of fighting left so we will see. Who he fights in the future and how he does could change my, and everybody else's opinion.

The UK is not a race.

[1g5a22]

Top 25 of the last THIRTY years? Get serious...

And why would the "yank SMW's" go to the UK to fight him? Tell me...why in the world would, Roy Jones, for instance, want to do that in 2000?

you reinforce my every perception of an american.....

[bsrizpac]

you reinforce my every perception of an american.....

And pray tell what must that be?

You reinforce my perceptions of UK boxing fans: Not realizing that this sport is primarily housed in America, no matter what delusions they harbor.

Meanwhile you take internet boxing debate and stereotype and entire society and it's everyday aspects as opposed to just it's boxing fans' knowledge. Good job.

[1g5a22]

And pray tell what must that be?

You reinforce my perceptions of UK boxing fans: Not realizing that this sport is primarily housed in America, no matter what delusions they harbor.

Meanwhile you take internet boxing debate and stereotype and entire society and it's everyday aspects as opposed to just it's boxing fans' knowledge. Good job.

again case proven,see above!!

"and stereotype and entire society" elaborate it doesnt make any sense,i think u mean an entire..

do none of you have nothing other than an introspective way of thinking,your self obsession amuses me

and dont delude YOURSELF into thinking that country doesnt come into it,both sides are guilty of that,and lessons in morality and delusion from someone who espouses unequivocal american bias hahahahaha,oh the irony....

next it will be the marquess of queensbury is american too....actually i think thats paulie mallinaggis alter ego........