My P4P list - Agree or Disagree ?

[KnockoutTheFat]

p4p boxing list is beneath tye , ko.

he belongs in the most powerful man ever list.

1. Tye Fields
2. Alexander the Great
3. Augustus Caesar
4. Julius Caesar
5. Napoleon Bonaparte

Pfff...
It's ridiculous that you even compare these mortals to the legendary Tye "****in'" Fields. What the hell has Napoleon ever done to become great?

[Left Hook Tua]

Pfff...
It's ridiculous that you even compare these mortals to the legendary Tye "****in'" Fields. What the hell has Napoleon ever done to become great?

napoleon do?

he got the french to fight. that's not an easy thing to do!!! :-)

when was the last time the germans feared the french? ha ha ha

remember , the french plant trees along the champs-elysees so that the germans can be comfortable marching in the shade......

[KnockoutTheFat]

napoleon do?

he got the french to fight. that's not an easy thing to do!!! :-)

when was the last time the germans feared the french? ha ha ha

remember , the french plant trees along the champs-elysees so that the germans can be comfortable marching in the shade......

Getting the French to fight is impressive, but it pales in comparison to a Tye Fields 1st round KO. A Fields 1st round KO can go back for centuries. When you talk to your grandkids who are you going to be talking about? How Napoleon got the French to fight, or how you survived a Tye Fields KO?

[pelonxsoldier28]

let me get this straight, some of you have calzaghe at number 2 on the p4p ratings cause he beat lacy, bika, manfredo, kessler, and hopkins? not on my list.

[KILLA RIGHT]

1.floyd
2.jmm
3.calzaghe
4.cotto
5.pac
6.marquez
7.vasquez
8.pavlik
9.ivan Calderon
10.too Many At 10

[luv3s2sp00g3]

the top 3 should be floyd, pac, calzaghe in that order. no exceptions.

[P4P Opinion]

1. mayweather
2. calzaghe
3. pacquiao
4. cotto
5. vazquez

Spot on. I find it very difficult to complete a top ten P4P list, but the top five are clear even if you'd rearrange the order.

[Naps]

I'm not going to debate the arrangement of the fighters, we sail this boat every time someone posts their P4P list updated.

But I will say I have no clue why you guys put Heavyweights on a P4P list.

They're the supreme weight, and it basically nullifies any comparison to lower weights.........when they're fighting against the biggest, strongest, hardest hitting, most durable fighters on average.

P4P means hypothetically, who has the best skills if they were all the same weight. You have it wrong mate.

[P4P Opinion]

let me get this straight, some of you have calzaghe at number 2 on the p4p ratings cause he beat lacy, bika, manfredo, kessler, and hopkins? not on my list.

Yes, we do, although I didn't take the Bika or Manfredo fight into account. I do take the Eubank fight, the Reid fight, the Woodhall fight, the Brewer fight and the Mitchell fight into account though (all former champions).

You dissapoint me, especially considering you're a Chargers fans like myself.

[slicksouthpaw16]

1.Floyd Mayweatherr Jr
2.Manny pacquiao
3.Joe calzaghe
4.Miguel cotto
5.Israel vazquez
6.kelly Pavlik
7.Bernard Hopkins
8.Juan Manual Marquez
9. Ivan Calderon
10. Chad Dawson