SOME Cotto Fans ARE making ALL COTTO fans LOOK BAD..!!!

[Vladimir303]

totally agree! Let's compare Floyd with Oscar cause Cotto started at 140!
Mayweather Oscar
Hernandez,Corrales,Chavez Hernandez,Chavez,Withaker,
Castillo,Gatti,JudahHatton,DLH Camacho,Gatti,Mosley,
Trinidad,Vargas,Hopkins,PBF

That also doesn't make sense since Floyd framewise is a smaller guy then Oscar. Oscar starved himself to make 130 and win a title. He spend the majority of his career at welterweight at jr.middle. And a few of the opponents you listed are at jr.middle where Floyd only fought once and beat Oscar.

If you really agree with the post you agreed with then you shouldn't have made this post.

Eventually all that matters is Head-to-Head. Hatton Ko'd Castillo with a bodyshot while Floyd struggled with him in the first fight, yet Floyd cartoonishly Ko'd Hatton back to Manchaster.

Head-to-head he defeated Oscar. That's how you solve the arguement.

[AntonTheMeh]

and i'd like to know who the **** did chico beat to be top 5 p4p.give me a break.he and castillo made each other.

[GTL]

and i'd like to know who the **** did chico beat to be top 5 p4p.give me a break.he and castillo made each other.

in all fairness.. chico was top 10 p4p..

most experts picked him to win

[Vladimir303]

and i'd like to know who the **** did chico beat to be top 5 p4p.give me a break.he and castillo made each other.

Chico was undefeated and has beaten the best super-feathers around at that time. Floyd as a WBC super-featherweight champion was also P4P top 10 at theat time but Chico was ahead. Many had him as the favorite coming into the fight against Floyd due to his destruction of previous opponents. In fact you could say he was what Cotto is now.

And then the Floyd Mayweather fight happened......

[IwatchBoxing]

Cottos just getting experince in, he'll soon show up as the Cotto who fought Pinto, now with his new found experince at 27, hes been lagging around latey but he'll snap out it eventually, hopefully by Margarito.

[Pugilistic™]

can we get over the mayweather vs cotto ****

[Lazy Liberal]

That also doesn't make sense since Floyd framewise is a smaller guy then Oscar. Oscar starved himself to make 130 and win a title. He spend the majority of his career at welterweight at jr.middle. And a few of the opponents you listed are at jr.middle where Floyd only fought once and beat Oscar.

If you really agree with the post you agreed with then you shouldn't have made this post.

Eventually all that matters is Head-to-Head. Hatton Ko'd Castillo with a bodyshot while Floyd struggled with him in the first fight, yet Floyd cartoonishly Ko'd Hatton back to Manchaster.

Head-to-head he defeated Oscar. That's how you solve the arguement.

What does frame have to do with anything? If thats the case, diego Corrales accomplishemnt at 130 and 135 should be dismissed. Osacr and Floyd both started at 130, dont matter if if your a midget or bigfoot, both started at that weight.


I really do not believe taht Floyd would be eager to fight Tito,Whitaker,Quartey or Chavez.

[AntonTheMeh]

i know he was top 10.not top five.still who did he beat to merit him being top 10?

[THe TRiNiTY]

The problem with the logic behind Horus' argument is that Mayweatyher beat them all at a young age. Wonderful. So he developed faster then Cotto. Great. Has nothing to do with Cotto's ability to beat Mayweather, or his lack of said ability.

The fact that people try to argue over who would win, and make it seem as if they don't even want the fight to happen, befuddles me. If Cotto is such easy work for Mayweather, then have them fight already. Mayweather fans should be pushing for the fight if it's such easy work. Get rid of the hypejob. Some people just make no sense.

[Lazy Liberal]

i know he was top 10.not top five.still who did he beat to merit him being top 10?

Is that Floyd in your sig? you know, the greatest of all time.