Dan Rafael's P4P List (4/23)

[KingTito]

I would have Pacquiao over Calzaghe.

[Diego Morales]

If Manny ain't one right now I don't think he can do anything to be #1, I put him by far #1 right NOW!!!!

[kayjay]

either Dangenda doesn't watch the little fighters or has a dislike for them because you could make a case for Mijares, Solis, and Montiel rating higher than the part time fighter Oscar, Chris John maybe even Shane. Also guys like Haye, Abraham, Casamayor could make the lower half of his 20

I like that he pays no atention to the little men. I never include anyone fighting below 130 either as I consider it the same as women's boxing.

The second bolded is on point though

[J_CON]

Wlad not in the top 20?

[AntonTheMeh]

You do know that Margarito lost his title two fights ago against Paul Williams, right? So, if he has only won 2 fights in a row, what makes you think he deserves P4P status?

I agree with the top 4.
5. Izzy Vazquez
6. Cotto
7. Rafa Marquez
8. Pavlik
9. B-Hop
10. Calderon

did you see the fight?was it a landslide?no.just cause you lose a fight doesn't make you a worse fighter.hopkins lost twice to jermain,how much longer has hop been on that **** since he lost?

[PRboxingfan]

did you see the fight?was it a landslide?no.just cause you lose a fight doesn't make you a worse fighter.hopkins lost twice to jermain,how much longer has hop been on that **** since he lost?

Yeah, and B-Hop was always below Jermain in the rankings until he lost to Pavlik.

Of course I saw the fight. Williams won 8 rounds to 4, AFAIC. That means that Williams won twice as many rounds as Tony, right?

Also, Margarito wasn't top 10 BEFORE he lost to Williams; what has he done since to move into the list? Beat a C-Class fighter in Golden Johnson and KO Cintron, who also wasn't even close to the top 20 P4P? Margarito is lucky to break the top 20, pana.

Also, according to your statement (the one I bolded), PBF would still be #1 if he lost in his next fight, right? I mean, just because he loses a fight doesn't mean he's a worse fighter. He should be P4P #1 for the rest of eternity!

[AntonTheMeh]

Yeah, and B-Hop was always below Jermain in the rankings until he lost to Pavlik.

Of course I saw the fight. Williams won 8 rounds to 4, AFAIC. That means that Williams won twice as many rounds as Tony, right?

Also, Margarito wasn't top 10 BEFORE he lost to Williams; what has he done since to move into the list? Beat a C-Class fighter in Golden Johnson and KO Cintron, who also wasn't even close to the top 20 P4P? Margarito is lucky to break the top 20, pana.

Also, according to your statement (the one I bolded), PBF would still be #1 if he lost in his next fight, right? I mean, just because he loses a fight doesn't mean he's a worse fighter. He should be P4P #1 for the rest of eternity!

not by my standards.the point is these fighters don't drop that much when they lose,and fact is with out all the other bull**** you can think off margo is one of the top ten p4p fighter in the world.regardless.at the moment at least.

[tito yuca]

"Quick -- can you name one Pacquiao fight that was dull? Didn't think so."

Yeah, the Barrera rematch. And even if it was not dull, what does that have to do with anything? If P4P ranking was based on excitement then Gatti would have always been P4P #1

Oh, and PRBoxingFan, your last post is 100% right

[PRboxingfan]

not by my standards.the point is these fighters don't drop that much when they lose,and fact is with out all the other bull**** you can think off margo is one of the top ten p4p fighter in the world.regardless.at the moment at least.

I can name at least 20 fighters I'd rank above him. That's the beauty of P4P, it's subjective.

[DuttyAlacrity]

for being a titlist for 3 years welter.and having the floyd duck him,and gaining a belt again.**** head.

I respect your opinion but margo was beat decisively by Paul Williams