New Ring Magazine P4P List: Calzaghe overtakes Marquez to #3 spot

[Easy-E]

Seems fine to me.
I really wish you had made this poll public so we could see all the people who said Joe should be #1.

[ottoevans]

I have Pacman #1 , Floyd has picked his opponents wisely but hes still the best boxer out there based on his ability. But i would have to go with Pacman with what hes accomplished in the recent years

[wmute]

I have Pacman #1 , Floyd has picked his opponents wisely but hes still the best boxer out there based on his ability. But i would have to go with Pacman with what hes accomplished in the recent years

I agree 100%.

Mayweather should find himself some past his prime mexican fighters from 140 and fight them at 147, so that he could really claim to be the best. To really prove he was the best, he should get them while they come off losses or lackluster performances.

[wmute]

Hopkins at 5 is too high, and he was also too high at 3.

Maybe it is just me.

[miron_lang]

I agree 100%.

Mayweather should find himself some past his prime mexican fighters from 140 and fight them at 147, so that he could really claim to be the best. To really prove he was the best, he should get them while they come off losses or lackluster performances.

or he could rematch Hatton after DLH and then a rematch againts Baldomir and Judah to keep himself where he is right now.

[Addison]

Do you agree with The Ring ratings?

Last Week:

1 FLOYD MAYWEATHER
2 MANNY PACQUIAO
3 JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ
4 BERNARD HOPKINS
5 JOE CALZAGHE
6 ISRAEL VAZQUEZ
7 MIGUEL COTTO
8 RICKY HATTON
9 KELLY PAVLIK
10 RAFAEL MARQUEZ


After Calzaghe SD Hopkins

1 FLOYD MAYWEATHER
2 MANNY PACQUIAO
3 JOE CALZAGHE
4 JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ
5 BERNARD HOPKINS
6 ISRAEL VAZQUEZ
7 MIGUEL COTTO
8 RICKY HATTON
9 KELLY PAVLIK
10 RAFAEL MARQUEZ

Source: http://www.thering-online.com/ringpages/ratings2.html

P4P Vazquez looks way better than both of them.

[wmute]

or he could rematch Hatton after DLH and then a rematch againts Baldomir and Judah to keep himself where he is right now.

I agree 100%. Without older, small, just beaten mexicans available, he has to take the second most pathetic route to money, and leave true greatness to those who have old mexicans at hand.

[Jim Jeffries]

Isn't Hopkins 2-3 in his last five fights?

#5 p4p?

What a completely worthless list.