New Ring Magazine P4P List: Calzaghe overtakes Marquez to #3 spot

[SuckaPunch]

Do you agree with The Ring ratings?

Last Week:

1 FLOYD MAYWEATHER
2 MANNY PACQUIAO
3 JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ
4 BERNARD HOPKINS
5 JOE CALZAGHE
6 ISRAEL VAZQUEZ
7 MIGUEL COTTO
8 RICKY HATTON
9 KELLY PAVLIK
10 RAFAEL MARQUEZ


After Calzaghe SD Hopkins

1 FLOYD MAYWEATHER
2 MANNY PACQUIAO
3 JOE CALZAGHE
4 JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ
5 BERNARD HOPKINS
6 ISRAEL VAZQUEZ
7 MIGUEL COTTO
8 RICKY HATTON
9 KELLY PAVLIK
10 RAFAEL MARQUEZ

Source: http://www.thering-online.com/ringpages/ratings2.html

[Mr. Ryan]

Marquez dropped a decision to Pacquiao and lost some steam, and Calzaghe beat Hopkins so yeah, I'd agree with the list.

[KingTito]

Yea, that's fine.

[Sealhound]

I see why Cotto made the comments along the lines of not understanding why Floyd is still ranked number 1. I mean he has never even fought a true welterweight right? Still I think those are good rankings, expect Cotto to only increase his ranking.

[frankpaganini]

Calzaghe at 3 sounds right to me
Ricky Hatton shouldnt even be on the top 10 p4p list.

[mikec]

I see why Cotto made the comments along the lines of not understanding why Floyd is still ranked number 1. I mean he has never even fought a true welterweight right? Still I think those are good rankings, expect Cotto to only increase his ranking.

Hatton is ranked way too high! He shouldnt be in the top 10 maybe 11 or 12.... my concern with Joe is why did hestruggle against BHOP so much when BHOp is 43 yrs old? But he beat a legend who is way past his prime so it has to count for something.

[Sealhound]

Hatton is ranked way too high! He shouldnt be in the top 10 maybe 11 or 12.... my concern with Joe is why did hestruggle against BHOP so much when BHOp is 43 yrs old? But he beat a legend who is way past his prime so it has to count for something.

Meh, B-hop has a bunch of good wins in his old age. And yer Hatton I think should be top 15. I think David Haye will also be top 10 after ~5 fights at heavy weight.

[ElGranLuchador]

hopkins should drop to 7 behind vazquez and cotto

[Ramamaiden]

ohhh...i was just gonna do a thread about the new ring p4p rnkings :P

btw i agree with cal being at 3...

[Scoooter]

Klitschko should be up there. Well, top 20 maybe.