So is Calzaghe the P4P #1 Fighter Now?

[thegreatone1]

You are right regarding Lacy as a good contender at the time (no "next Mike Tyson" by any stretch though)... but it's 2008 and that is a 2006 fight. Cotto defeated Judah and Mosley... and a year has not passed. I think this is about being the best P4P fighter, 2008.

I should have clarified that what I said is regarding to the P4P top ten, April 2008. Thought the context of the post was enough.

After Judah lost to Baldomir and Mayweather

[thegreatone1]

So both Zab Judah and Shane Mosley are farther from their prime than Bernard Hopkins?

Neither had just beat fighters 20% of that calibre of Tarver and Wright.

[Ras44]

Neither had just beat fighters 20% of that calibre of Tarver and Wright.

So are they farther from their prime than Hopkins or not?

[Ras44]

Also worth considering, Joe Calzaghe won by a split decision, and was even knocked down during the fight.

Mayweather ko'd Hatton, won SD to DLH without being knocked down.
Cotto KO'd Judah, UD'd Mosley and last week KO'd Gómez (who could not being KO'd by Calzaghe's victim, Mr. Manfredo).

[Sin City]

hell to the no!