If Joe wins convincingly tonight, should he be P4P #1?

[MightyMikeA]

What do we have to look forward to from Mayweather? Another pointless De La Hoya rematch or him beating up on Junior Welterweights and avoiding all the stiff top comp at 147 like Cotto and Margarito? Should the best P4P fighter on the planet be a guy who seeks easy pay days in the world of fantasy make-believe that is the WWE?

I say if Joe Calzaghe wins convincingly tonight, he should unequivocably be regarded as the best fighter on the planet based solely on his last few fights and his defeat of a future hall of famer and legend that B-Hop is. What do you guys think?

[T-97]

I dunno, I have Pac at 2 right now so i dont think Joe could jump right up to number 1 but...

[Primal Instinx]

Check out the video that says Joe Calzaghe vs B-HOP prediction on the Video Trading Block section of boxingscene and you will see an opinion of who is #1 p4p after the fight.

[BKM-]

Top 3 for sure. Number 1..not sure either.

[msagrain]

it depends if he beats him and how easy he beats him. But you can always says someone elses style can beat him.

[RichCCFC]

I think it would solidify his top 2 status but I don't know if it's enough to take Mayweathers crown.

A win over Pavlik would do that though, IMO.

[Addition]

No he shouldn't.

[Ironside]

#3, I find it really hard to take Pacman's and PBF's spots.

[niceguy45]

calzaghe deservces the spot,
over anyone if he beats b-hop...

[SkilledB]

no, this is his first fight out of SWM
floyd went from 130 to 154, thats more the 1 division.
Maybe if he beats Hopkins, Possibly a roy jones or a pavlik that may but i doubt it, i don't think he will even get past hopkins