Voted for the best Welterweight

[Sin City]

Very interesting to see the poll be a virtual tie and so close between Cotto and Mayweather.. more reason for the fight to happen.

[Killa Cam]

PHYSICALLY/SKILLWISE...Zab Judah, an dont even front like he aint got tha most raw talent

ACCOMPLISHMENTS...right now it between pbf/mosley

MENTALLY...alfonso gomez until he fought Cotto

OVERALL...i gotta say we find out after PBF fight Cotto, winner of that is best overall WW fighter of our time

[mcentepede]

I agree with that last guy...Mosley was so talented...even though he has 5 losses now, he has never been stopped and showed well vs. Cotto. At age 36, I had the fight a draw. You get the feeling, if he gets in shape he can beat everybody on the list. Also Tito fought everybody, ducking no-one, and mostly lost to bigger guys (no welterweight beat him), he gets points for that. Mayweather is talented but he the most boring on the list.

[thegreatone1]

the if's and what if's don't count. go off of cotto's last 8 fights and floyd's last 8 fights. i mean, ****, did cotto not fight corley, sosa, and judah after mayweather? hello? and for 2501, that's some truth hurts for your ass boy.

do you consider torres better than n'dou or more accomplished than gatti? was gatti not the wbc jr welterweight champion when he fought floyd? was de la hoya not an accomplished fighter who cotto himself made known he wanted to fight? again, did mosley not openly duck floyd in 2006, hence the reason why he fought baldomir who was at that time more accomplished than margarito. i'll give cotto quitana because he was undfeated and just beat paul williams but looking back at that win, the only reason it's so significant now, is because carlos beat paul, that's all. of course, cotto knocked him out, so i'll give him that. but branco? please boy. and i'll give cotto malanaggi, because is a great boxer, and was undefeated and gaev cotto a fight. so, i'll give cotto paulie, quiatana, mosley, and judah, and maybe eeven tony if he beats him. but, floyd has gatti, baldomir, hatton, oscar, judah, and n'dou, a knockout artist. i'll even take off baldi and give cotto torres, and floyd's last 9 fights ****s on cotto's.

I didnt read your rabid ramble after the first insult.

Look at the last 9 fights Cotto has faced the much better fighters.

Its in black and white we could go back further but to go beyond 5yrs is irrelevant.

[Sugarj]

Some comedy voting here, short memories strike again. Even the much faded, older Shane Mosley gave Cotto a close fight a few months ago, just imagine if the Mosley of eight years ago was there.

I personally would take the Mosley that beat De La Hoya the first time over a peak Mayweather. Shane was even faster than Floyd, had harder one punch power and threw more punches and combinations per round. Its crazy that Cotto has all these votes.

[DrewWoodside]

Some comedy voting here, short memories strike again. Even the much faded, older Shane Mosley gave Cotto a close fight a few months ago, just imagine if the Mosley of eight years ago was there.

I personally would take the Mosley that beat De La Hoya the first time over a peak Mayweather. Shane was even faster than Floyd, had harder one punch power and threw more punches and combinations per round. Its crazy that Cotto has all these votes.

Cotto beating Mosley might have been part of the reason people found it so easy to take him over Mosley.

[DrewWoodside]

Cotto beating Mosley might have been part of the reason people found it so easy to take him over Mosley.

I wanna hear more from the guy who picked Paul Williams.

[Rompeboca]

nobody got Quintana's back?

[Rane-Ex54]

Can I ask 2 questions. 1) Why is ODLH on this list? 2) Who n the hell voted for him??