My take and prediction on Cotto Vs Margarito

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Shalafi
    Banned
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Dec 2007
    • 3080
    • 88
    • 53
    • 3,357

    #1

    My take and prediction on Cotto Vs Margarito

    Tough fight to predict since both fighters are amazing, and they are extremely effective in what they do.
    First let me list both their strengths and weaknesses and try to come out with a well thought-out conclusion.

    (Remember this is all subjective and is based on my own personal opinion).

    Cotto:

    Strengths

    . Big puncher (devastating left hook to the body).
    . Strong and snappy jab
    . Tough (both mentally and physically)
    . Improved footwork
    . Improved lateral movement
    . Good punch speed
    . Younger and in his prime

    Weaknesses

    . Weak Chin (still debatable by some)
    . Subpar defense (tends to leave himself open on the inside, uses earmuff guard therefore prone to big uppercuts, see the Judah fight)
    . Shorter height (this could either benefit him or not against a bigger guy like Margarito)
    . Has not really been pressured (Shane fought him toe-to-toe and Cotto looked a bit uncomfortable at times, since he's always played the role of the aggressor)
    . Becoming a little arrogant (as shown on the Gomez fight, again this could either benefit him or defeat him)

    Margarito

    Strengths

    . Excellent punching power
    . Pressure fighter (throws 100+ punches per round)
    . Excellent inside work
    . Lethal uppercuts
    . Chin (nothing else can be said about this)
    . Tough (both mentally and physically)
    . The bigger man of the two
    . Hungrier at this point

    Weaknesses

    . Slower puncher
    . Slower movement
    . Subpar guard (although I think he keeps his hands up better than Cotto, blocks a lot of punches with his gloves)
    . Lazy jab
    . Age factor/mileage (although they are only 2 and change years apart, Tony has been in more wars than Cotto and it's been fighting since he was 15)

    I see Cotto starting out faster than Tony, throwing that snappy jab, landing more and keeping Tony at bay and using his better speed to come in and throw a few hooks to the body to establish his power, and then move away. Tony will keep pressuring Cotto in the later rounds landing and missing a lot of times but will not be slowed down by Cotto until the later rounds. Cotto by now will not move as fast as he did on the first rounds, Tony will start connecting on the inside landing stronger punches on a worn out Cotto, Margarito's chin being the edge factor of the fight. By round 10 or 11 both fighters will be hanging by a thread from the punishment inflicted to each other. If Cotto has not been able to stop Tony by these rounds, he won't be able to do it for the remaining rounds of the fight (again, chin being the factor), Cotto will try to use the last few drops of gas on his tank to try and box a slower Tony into a decision. However if Tony manages to connect in the last rounds, he will drop Cotto and win by TKO and win the fight. If Cotto somehow manages to survive the last 2 rounds of the fight, he will win by decision. I think when it comes down to it, the man who wants it more and whoever has the most will win this fight.
  • Doctor Sam
    Up and Comer
    Interim Champion - 1-100 posts
    • Nov 2007
    • 58
    • 2
    • 0
    • 6,104

    #2
    Originally posted by Shalafi
    Tough fight to predict since both fighters are amazing, and they are extremely effective in what they do.
    First let me list both their strengths and weaknesses and try to come out with a well thought-out conclusion.

    (Remember this is all subjective and is based on my own personal opinion).

    Cotto:

    Strengths

    . Big puncher (devastating left hook to the body).
    . Strong and snappy jab
    . Tough (both mentally and physically)
    . Improved footwork
    . Improved lateral movement
    . Good punch speed
    . Younger and in his prime

    Weaknesses

    . Weak Chin (still debatable by some)
    . Subpar defense (tends to leave himself open on the inside, uses earmuff guard therefore prone to big uppercuts, see the Judah fight)
    . Shorter height (this could either benefit him or not against a bigger guy like Margarito)
    . Has not really been pressured (Shane fought him toe-to-toe and Cotto looked a bit uncomfortable at times, since he's always played the role of the aggressor)
    . Becoming a little arrogant (as shown on the Gomez fight, again this could either benefit him or defeat him)

    Margarito

    Strengths

    . Excellent punching power
    . Pressure fighter (throws 100+ punches per round)
    . Excellent inside work
    . Lethal uppercuts
    . Chin (nothing else can be said about this)
    . Tough (both mentally and physically)
    . The bigger man of the two
    . Hungrier at this point

    Weaknesses

    . Slower puncher
    . Slower movement
    . Subpar guard (although I think he keeps his hands up better than Cotto, blocks a lot of punches with his gloves)
    . Lazy jab
    . Age factor/mileage (although they are only 2 and change years apart, Tony has been in more wars than Cotto and it's been fighting since he was 15)

    I see Cotto starting out faster than Tony, throwing that snappy jab, landing more and keeping Tony at bay and using his better speed to come in and throw a few hooks to the body to establish his power, and then move away. Tony will keep pressuring Cotto in the later rounds landing and missing a lot of times but will not be slowed down by Cotto until the later rounds. Cotto by now will not move as fast as he did on the first rounds, Tony will start connecting on the inside landing stronger punches on a worn out Cotto, Margarito's chin being the edge factor of the fight. By round 10 or 11 both fighters will be hanging by a thread from the punishment inflicted to each other. If Cotto has not been able to stop Tony by these rounds, he won't be able to do it for the remaining rounds of the fight (again, chin being the factor), Cotto will try to use the last few drops of gas on his tank to try and box a slower Tony into a decision. However if Tony manages to connect in the last rounds, he will drop Cotto and win by TKO and win the fight. If Cotto somehow manages to survive the last 2 rounds of the fight, he will win by decision. I think when it comes down to it, the man who wants it more and whoever has the most will win this fight.
    Very interesting insite, though i cant help but feel its gonna be a more lopsided version of the mosley cotto fight not meaning to compare margarito to mosely. But i mean that there will be alot of action in the beginning and if Cotto is up i believe he will probally get on his bike and move around for the UD. I hope Margarito is able to make a fight out of it. Then again im not to sure about cotto being able to box Margarito to much from the outside since he is 4-5 inches shorter with im guessing a smaller reach. So the jab might be out of the question. If that is the case, i see the fight being much closer since they will have to engage each other more in the middle of the ring. This is where Cotto might have some big problems. Further analysis to come....

    Comment

    • THE REED
      Sixty Forty
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Apr 2007
      • 43489
      • 1,992
      • 1,483
      • 690,068,075

      #3
      i like cake, definitely.

      Comment

      • Shalafi
        Banned
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Dec 2007
        • 3080
        • 88
        • 53
        • 3,357

        #4
        Originally posted by Doctor Sam
        Very interesting insite, though i cant help but feel its gonna be a more lopsided version of the mosley cotto fight not meaning to compare margarito to mosely. But i mean that there will be alot of action in the beginning and if Cotto is up i believe he will probally get on his bike and move around for the UD. I hope Margarito is able to make a fight out of it. Then again im not to sure about cotto being able to box Margarito to much from the outside since he is 4-5 inches shorter with im guessing a smaller reach. So the jab might be out of the question. If that is the case, i see the fight being much closer since they will have to engage each other more in the middle of the ring. This is where Cotto might have some big problems. Further analysis to come....
        Good point Sam, that's why I listed the height advantages/disadvantages, the only way I think Cotto might land the jabs is by stepping inside Tony, or by using angles (he showed on the Gomez fight he can move better than before)

        Comment

        • THE REED
          Sixty Forty
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Apr 2007
          • 43489
          • 1,992
          • 1,483
          • 690,068,075

          #5
          The jab is NOT out of the question... Reach isnt as important as timing, for a jab. Mike Tyson proved that completely.

          Comment

          • Shalafi
            Banned
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Dec 2007
            • 3080
            • 88
            • 53
            • 3,357

            #6
            Originally posted by reedickyaluss
            The jab is NOT out of the question... Reach isnt as important as timing, for a jab. Mike Tyson proved that completely.
            Yes you are right as well.

            Comment

            • MANGLER
              Sex Tape Flop Artist
              Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
              • Feb 2008
              • 30142
              • 1,705
              • 2,355
              • 46,598

              #7
              If Tony wins it will be by doin what he always does, comin forward all night and outworkin his guy. Same for Cotto, comin forward and smashin the body to pieces. Either guy can win it by I'd take Tony by close decision.

              Comment

              • Shalafi
                Banned
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Dec 2007
                • 3080
                • 88
                • 53
                • 3,357

                #8
                I forgot to add Stamina in the advantages/weaknesses of each fighter. I think they both have good stamina but Tony is more of a workhorse and can last the 12 rounds no problem, I feel that Cotto puts a lot of extra power to his shots and also by being the quicker fighter it tends to drain more stamina than normal. I think Tony also has the edge on this department, just my observation.

                Comment

                • Undefeated
                  MasterMind
                  Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                  • Nov 2005
                  • 9366
                  • 392
                  • 280
                  • 17,529

                  #9
                  Movement is a problem to any fighter who relys on throwing 100 punches per round and trying to land in the process. Im sure Tony will tone down that output when he faces Cotto.

                  Good insites though, but Tony has suspect defense aswell. Should be interesting, but I think Cotto's body work might take effect in this fight, and even better if he devotes his power to ever single shot.


                  The height should'nt be a problem, cause it makes it easier for Cotto to land those inside hooks.

                  Look at the Pinto fight, (Not comparing Pinto to Tony) but height shouldn't be a problem. Cotto will make Tony miss at points in the fight. Mark my words. Its just how I see it. I don't see Cotto getting hurt. He got hurt with shots that he barely even seen and by fast punchers.

                  Comment

                  • AntonTheMeh
                    STOP CRYIN
                    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                    • Sep 2007
                    • 21222
                    • 700
                    • 709
                    • 31,623

                    #10
                    I DIDN'T BOTHER READING.i know who you root for there was no need for this thread is obvious.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP