P4P - Greatest of all time - Joe Calzaghe?

[Mr. Philadel]

44 fights without a future Hall Famer isnt what I would call taking the place of Ray Robinson! Enzo isnt REALLY a boxing guy, but Joe is and you can tell he was a bit uncomfortable after his pops made those remarks! Joe isnt close to becoming p4p greatest of all-time, NOONE is! Ray Robinson is the p4p g.o.a.t. and dont let noone tell you anything different!

[deanrw]

Whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaat dude.

wait... gun? or no gun?

They all musta forgot!

[Left Hook Tua]

ahahahahahahaha

how bout my poll

if the boy roy never left 168.... joe would be a car insurance salesman

nope. calzaghe would be undefeated at 175. well...MAYBE undefeated. he wouldn't be at 168 that i know for sure. his record has been well protected.

[BennyST]

Just heard that from Enzo Calzaghe himself.

Is there any way he could back up these claims?

Maybe he beats Hopkins, Pavik, then RJJ? Is he one then?

He has to have a chance.

?

Possibly in SMW. But actual pound for pound, no way. Even if he beats all those guys, which he very well could, he would or should not be considered a P4P great. He should be considered a great in terms of remaining undefeated properly ala Marciano and making an amazing number of defenses and being a massively underrated fighter, because he really is very damn good, but all time pound for pound? No chance!

[BennyST]

44 fights without a future Hall Famer isnt what I would call taking the place of Ray Robinson! Enzo isnt REALLY a boxing guy, but Joe is and you can tell he was a bit uncomfortable after his pops made those remarks! Joe isnt close to becoming p4p greatest of all-time, NOONE is! Ray Robinson is the p4p g.o.a.t. and dont let noone tell you anything different!

Yo man, you crazy? or what?

Mayweather the damn greatess o' all time, no doubt boy!

Robinson don have **** compared to my man Money! He da most complex and integral fighter ever. He an artist, a sculptor, an entrepreneur, a true creator at work and a genius of da modern age baby!

He make money while I gi' him mine! Yo dig? He da fatch no fizzle on da wackin dough boy schnizzle pizzle!

[Don Gorgon]

I think Enzo Calzaghe is slowly starting to lose the plot, he's becoming an embarassment. His comments before the Haye v Macca fight was bad enough, but now this?

I can only guess there was a little kidology going on there, he probably wanted to provoke a reaction. To encourage more people to watch his boy.

He's probably the greatest Brit P4P of all time, even that is arguable. . .

[Chunk..]

You miss my point, Chunk. There is no point in me trying to enlighten you, I'd just be spitting out my opinion and you probably wouldn't value it.

Probably because you're a Calzaghe fan and so your answer would probably speak for itself.

[BetterCallSaul]

Joe is in my book, the most naturally talented boxer out there today. Is he p4p atg...no. But if he beats Hopkins, RJJ and Pavlik, I have no doubts about him being the greatest ever SMW and maybe Top 20 p4p atg.

Joe is a real fighter. He wins fights with his skill and knowledge of the ring. He does not rely on running away from fighters and picking his phantom punches to impress the judges.

Nobody puts on a show like joe,