Who will have Hopkins P4P#1 if he beats Calzaghe?

[P4PKING_2008]

My apologies if someone posted this already, I skimmed the first couple of pages for a thread.

If Hopkins beats Calzaghe, should he be bumped ahead of Floyd in the p4p standings?

Can an argument be made for Calzaghe if he beats Hopkins?

No way who has he beat? Look at his resume and compare it to the likes of Hopkins, Taylor, Wright people in his own division.

I rep LFCU so I picked the last one.

[Pullcounter]

My apologies if someone posted this already, I skimmed the first couple of pages for a thread.

If Hopkins beats Calzaghe, should he be bumped ahead of Floyd in the p4p standings?

Can an argument be made for Calzaghe if he beats Hopkins?

one could make an argument that if hopkins beats calzaghe then he will be p4p #1.

IMHO it depends on how Hopkins beats Calzaghe... if he squeaks by with a split decision or in a controversial decision, or a close Majority decision I say no. If he dominates Calzaghe like 8-4 rounds or he tKO or KOs Calzaghe, it's a very compelling argument.

[Boxing Chap]

If Bernard beat Calzaghe he must be placed at #1

[Pugilistic™]

no i would place him at no2

[215Chaingang]

i would put him at #1 cause of the three recent ranked fighters he beat and how old he is. (even thou i think floyd will be number 1) i just wish he would fight someone ranked or a welterweight