Who will have Hopkins P4P#1 if he beats Calzaghe?

[MetalVomit]

My apologies if someone posted this already, I skimmed the first couple of pages for a thread.

If Hopkins beats Calzaghe, should he be bumped ahead of Floyd in the p4p standings?

Can an argument be made for Calzaghe if he beats Hopkins?

[MetalVomit]

Damn, I expected at least a few replies. If he beats Calzaghe, he will have beaten Tarver, Winky and Calzaghe in succession.

[FRKO]

I voted YES.

[Boxinguru]

Floyd is my fav. fighter, but if B-Hop pulls this one off (considering he's 43), NO ONE can deny him of being the best fighter in the world & beating the best they have to offer...

[frankpaganini]

My apologies if someone posted this already, I skimmed the first couple of pages for a thread.

If Hopkins beats Calzaghe, should he be bumped ahead of Floyd in the p4p standings?

Can an argument be made for Calzaghe if he beats Hopkins?

if hopkins wins he cant go higher than 3rd without being bias (in my opinion)

if calzaghe wins hopkins just falls down on the p4p list while calzaghe would most likely stay at his spot (number 3).

i cant move mayweather or pacquiao down the list without a loss really or a terrible performance...

[MetalVomit]

if hopkins wins he cant go higher than 3rd without being bias (in my opinion)

if calzaghe wins hopkins just falls down on the p4p list while calzaghe would most likely stay at his spot (number 3).

i cant move mayweather or pacquiao down the list without a loss really or a terrible performance...

Solid argument.

[ExecutiveOutlaw]

i would have him #2 or maybe tied for #1, itd be impossible to tell with his age

[ИATAS]

I voted no on a similar thread, but after thinking about it - floyd hasn't fought anyone ranked in his division in years and pacman just barely snuck by marquez, so I think I would have Hopkins as #1 until Mayweather/pacman beat someone relevant.

[KingTito]

i dunno, i'd prolly put him at 2 or 3, more than likely 3

[Dirt E Gomez]

While what he'd be doing would be pretty remarkable, it's basically impossible to dethrone Floyd unless he really goes inactive or loses. It'd be tough to decide #2 or #3 w/ Pac's "win" over JMM.